Closing 6500 gallon outdoor pond, can I take any of my KOI with me into apartment??

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Damon0306

Gambusia
MFK Member
Jan 6, 2006
469
19
16
51
New Jersey
I recently moved from my parents home into a 2-bedroom apartment.

We have decided to close my natural/rock/gravel 6500-gallon pond, because being that I no longer live in the home, the maintenance for ME is just to much.

I have 16 koi in the pond, all purchased same time all aprox 8-10 inches in size.

With this fish load, the fact the pond is natural gravel, with no bottom drains, and the fact the pond is only 6500 gallons I must do frequent partial-water changes during the months the pond is running.

Last summer my water bill was aprox $800 every 4-months!!

Would it be possible to keep 4 of my 10-inch koi and raise them in a BARE-NO-GRAVEL=NO-POOP-TRAP 180-gallon-aquarium?

I relize this amount of water is very small for koi, and I know the rule of thumb is 1000-gallons of water per koi, but I think these rules could be bent quite a bit if you are willing to do the water changes without ever missing them.

I would setup the tank so filtering-power would be OVERKILL as well as using my very powerful outdoor HiBlow air pumps so that the water would be saturated with oxygen.

Most importantly MASSIVE DAILY 75% water changes with a dechlorinator.

Could this be done? I cannot see why it wouldn't work, water bills would no longer be an issue since my water is free.

Many years ago I kept Oscars in my basement in a 180 gallon tank, I had 8 adults at one point, they were fed heavy, but I never missed my water changes had overkill filter setup and the fish thrived, the only issues were with fighting between the fish sometimes.
 
i have had two koi in the house in a 55 all winter will put them outside in the pond next month.
 
get a decent filter and you would be able to keep them... just keep the water clean
 
It's doable, but your going to have to stay on top of things,

8x turnover rate.

Largest sump (over 75g prefer 100g) pre-filter/filter/heat/aerate in the sump.

Perhaps a bio-tower after the filter, it would save space.

If you can hook up a drip system it may help a little.

Weekly 35%-50% W/C's.

Dr Joe

.
 
is it really doable?> yes BUT is it fair?? NO

i would not want my fish swimming in a toilet bowl for my own gratifications

i think thats selfish on your part....I would say temperarily BUT no not permanent...


should re think what you are doing honestly

doug
 
if he is doing the water changes (although i think dr. joe's wc schedule is better than his proposed one) and has heavy filteration like he says he plans on doing, i don't see how that is a toilet bowl? That seems like good care to me.
I would get a wider tank or a large rubbermaid when they get bigger, but as for now, I think it is allright.
 
the difference is thriving verse surviving

you can keep a dog in a crate and it will survive, but is it thriving?

I said it can be done.....but should it??? its a moral issue here IMO not for the better of the fish....


can they live? yes......is it fair?? not IMO

doug
 
You should do at least a 300g rubbermaid tank. that way, you could still view them from above and they'd have more swimming space. I dont think any koi would be happy going from a 6500g pond to a 180g box
 
sumthingfishy;1625219; said:
they sell 300g???

yep, and other companies make larger ones.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com