View Full Version : Saltwater fish battle
Neo Baron
06-06-2005, 4:30 PM
which fish would win.
Bamboo shark, goliath grouper or aligator gar ( yes they can live in sw too.)
piranha45
06-06-2005, 4:32 PM
grouper would swallow them both whole and still be hungry
not much of a battle at all... grouper gets 12 feet long and weighs a ton or two, gator gar gets 10 feet and weights 400 lbs, bamboo shark gets 2 feet and weighs maybe 5 lbs
Vitaliy
06-06-2005, 4:33 PM
grouper would swallow them both whole and still be hungry
http://www.earthwave.org/gars/treegar.jpg
Good luck...
piranha45
06-06-2005, 4:35 PM
that pic is grossly distorted, that guy is probably standing 15 feet away from it, bring in a real pic lol
adult gator gars don't eat anything that doesnt fit in their mouths, and their mouths ain't **** compared to a 12' grouper.
like i said, not a fair fight whatsoever. and where the hell did bamboo shark come from, LOL. a 2-foot nurse shark? i mean jesus... :rofl:
neo's post is like asking what would win between a redtailed catfish, lima shovelnose and neon tetra. Well, one grows 5 feet, the other grows 20", the last grows 1" :y220d:
Neo Baron
06-06-2005, 4:43 PM
u really think the gator would lose, and the bamboo is for fun and so when noobs see the word shark they atomaticly choose shark.
Vitaliy
06-06-2005, 4:48 PM
that pic is grossly distorted, that guy is probably standing 15 feet away from it, bring in a real pic lol
adult gator gars don't eat anything that doesnt fit in their mouths, and their mouths ain't **** compared to a 12' grouper.
like i said, not a fair fight whatsoever. and where the hell did bamboo shark come from, LOL. a 2-foot nurse shark? i mean jesus... :rofl:
neo's post is like asking what would win between a redtailed catfish, lima shovelnose and neon tetra. Well, one grows 5 feet, the other grows 20", the last grows 1" :y220d:
I got my money on the NEON TETRA!
Show me a pic of a grouper that would swallow an alligator gar? I never seen one that big!
got bait?
06-06-2005, 4:51 PM
Goliath and not even close.
piranha45
06-06-2005, 4:52 PM
i was exaggerating... slightly. the grouper wouldn't have any trouble fitting half the gar in its mouth tho
http://www.stephanietyler.com/blog/archives/Record%20Grouper%201.jpg
got bait?
06-06-2005, 4:55 PM
hate pics like this, Goliaths are on the endangered species list. This kinda looks like a Black sea bass too.
Vitaliy
06-06-2005, 5:02 PM
neo's post is like asking what would win between a redtailed catfish, lima shovelnose and neon tetra. Well, one grows 5 feet, the other grows 20", the last grows 1" :y220d:
http://www.monsterfishkeepers.com/gallery/watermark.php?file=2/neon.jpg
I really did mean I got my money on the tetra!
(I got way too much time on my hands :shakehead )