Hey this waters a little salty!

[Jay R.]

well since this section was started as a result of a question of mine. I'll throw out the first pitch. what kinda saltwater monsters do you guys have out there?

would a crab fall under this catagory? i have a monster hermit crab.....
I also have a blue crab who is terrorizing my tank......... :rolleyes:

[The TRUST]

LOL!

Haven't really kept any monster SW fish before but one SW pred I really like is the Hawaiian Dragon Moray.
http://scubaduba.com/robinson/dragon_eel.jpg

[piranha45]

how big do blue crabs get? I do hear they are as aggressive a crustacean as you can get. Are they capable of killing fish near their own size?

[WckedMidas]

i can get you guys and gals all the blue crabs you could ever want. I live on the chesapeak bay home of the blue crab. I duno how agressive they are but they sure do hurt like hell when they pinch ya

[Jay R.]

well this guy comes darting out like a bat outta h#!! when its feeding time and swings at any fish that comes by. little bugger is a monster, even if not by deffinition!

[The TRUST]

Since ur in FL, why not fish for some sharks?

[Jay R.]

well this guy comes darting out like a bat outta h#!! when its feeding time and swings at any fish that comes by. little bugger is a monster, even if not by deffinition!

[Jay R.]

they are m,igrating right now. hundreds just off the beach. but i don't have the gear for that action!!

[The TRUST]

just hope u hook a tank size one. if it huge, cut the line!! LOL!

[Jay R.]

:D I'll have to hop in the water with a net and some bait and "hand" pick the one i want!! :eek:

[The TRUST]

careful. don't lose a toe, foot, leg or ur life.

[Jay R.]

not planning on it. i need those peices!!

[Rui]

I am sort of 'new' to marine - about 3 year now. My first 'monster' was the biggest Angler/Frogfish I have ever seen at a Petshop - about 9 inches. The only thing I could mix him with was a Lion fish, but he started showing some interest in him, so I decided to get rid of the angler before he ate my lion. Problem with keeping monsters in marine tanks is this: it is SOOOO hard to find another fish large enough to stick in with them, unless you are thinking of getting larger angels (most of the time, they won't eat if you buy them over a certain size).

Eventually I moved on to Morays. Bought a Fimbriated moray. Morays are horrible when they attack - they just won't let go. I blame myself for this little 'incident'. I had a 7 inch convict blenny - TERRORIZED the fimbriated moray. The moray was only 9 inches or so, but thinner. One day, I was feeding them pieces of shrimp. Two pieces were falling down. Moray came from behind the rocks, perched up, and kept looking side to side at two different falling pieces. The convict blenny moved in on one of them, and the moray must have seen some 'movement' and just striked. Caught the Blenny right behind the head, and pulled them blenny back behind all the live rock. I immediately tried to get a 'stick' to seperate them, but the moray had his body wrapped around the blenny (very similar to what a snake does). I then lost sight of the two of them again. About 5 seconds later, I saw the outcome - a decapitated convict blenny. I know the moray was not strong enough to bite through the blenny, but with it's tugging and biting combo, eventually popped the head off.

Morays have HORRIBLE eyes, and you need to pay attention when you feed them. They will snap without really knowing what they are snapping at. There was NO WAY the moray would have tried to eat the blenny.

I spent quite a long time looking for a Honeycomb moray. Gorgeous eels - second only to the Hawaiian Dragon Eel pictured above (will post my pics in the next few days of my pet). Eventually, somone traded their's in. Bought a 2 foot specimen, and with a good girth on him. Put him in with a 5 inch Pink Tailed Trigger and a 5 inch Porcupine Puffer. About 5 mths later, he took my trigger. He grabbed him sideways, pulling him through the expanse of live rock I invested in to make him comfortable. I have huge pieces of rock, and he pulled that trigger sideways through all the rock, moving 25 and 30lb pieces with ease. I took my net, and tried to 'choke' him into letting the trigger go, so I can at least stick him in my sump and bring him to the petshop to trade him, or just give him away at least. Didn't work. I tried using a stick..eventually just pushed his way through it. So strong! Saw him gulp him down :(

Every feeding time, he started taking a bite at the puffer. Puffer would blow up in his mouth. No way he could get him down I thought. Even if he doesn't blow up, the puffer is simply too wide to get down his throat - dislocating his jaws or not. Puffer showed no worse for wear, and he grew another inch and a half. Unfortunately, the eel grew another foot - just over 3 now, and THICK from the 2x/week feeding of 4 large sticklebacks, 1 large squid, 2 small sized octopi and 3 or 4 small anchovies - plus all the shrimp, scallops and everything else he 'stole' from the puffer.

One morning, I turn on the light, and the puffer was gone, and the eel had a fat stomach (and I swear, a smile you just knew came from winning).

Got rid of my eel 3 weeks ago now :(

By far, the easiest fish I have ever kept either fresh or saltwater.

[Jay R.]

wow, maybe I'll stick with the crabs

[The TRUST]

Wait a minute!?? Aren't Puffers poisonous? The eel didnt die?

[Rui]

I don't believe Porcupines are poisonous. Boxfish and trunkfish are, I believe. The eel showed absolutely no ill effects, so at the very least, whatever toxin the puffer had was negligible.

[guppy]

Blue crabs need cool water and will eat anything they can get hold of just like dungeness. They are also canibbals. I helped raise some for an aquaculture class.

[guppy]

Not all puffers are very toxic, tiger puffers, used for fugu, contain so much tetrado toxin that even a s**** of liver or roe will kill you. Maybe morays are resistant.

[Jay R.]

found an Ell today at the fish store, was at leats 2 feet long, very thin, called a ghost ell. I'm thinking thats a monster!

[Rui]

I stand corrected. P. puffers are toxic. But like most toxic animals in the sea, the bulk of the poisons is a direct result of food consumed. The following website is pretty interesting.

http://www.chemsoc.org/exemplarchem/entries/2004/icl_Quek/intro.htm

Another reason to explain why the eel was still alive (and I found other sites where honeycombs eating lionfish and porcupine puffers in other people's tanks) is that most tank-raised fish (not necessarily tank bred) do not have as potent of a toxin as wild fish. Puffers actually produce TTX, but certain foods might provide the necessary compounds needed to manufacture TTX. Other poisonous animals (triggers and others) obtain their chemical protection as a direct result of eating certain foods. In either case, these are almost always lacking in the aquarium, and thus, their poisons should be less powerful, though I still wouldn't eat a captive one :)

I just wonder if Eels will feed on P. Puffers in the wild, and if they survive. Something must eat these guys and be able to survive.

[guppy]

I stand corrected. P. puffers are toxic. But like most toxic animals in the sea, the bulk of the poisons is a direct result of food consumed. The following website is pretty interesting.

http://www.chemsoc.org/exemplarchem/entries/2004/icl_Quek/intro.htm

Another reason to explain why the eel was still alive (and I found other sites where honeycombs eating lionfish and porcupine puffers in other people's tanks) is that most tank-raised fish (not necessarily tank bred) do not have as potent of a toxin as wild fish. Puffers actually produce TTX, but certain foods might provide the necessary compounds needed to manufacture TTX. Other poisonous animals (triggers and others) obtain their chemical protection as a direct result of eating certain foods. In either case, these are almost always lacking in the aquarium, and thus, their poisons should be less powerful, though I still wouldn't eat a captive one :)

I just wonder if Eels will feed on P. Puffers in the wild, and if they survive. Something must eat these guys and be able to survive.
Makes sense, captive bred dart frogs will barely make a cat sick, some of the wild ones can put a hurt on you for just holding one in a bare hand. Some sea turtles eat boxjellies and man-o-wars that would kill most critters, and some birds like roadrunners and secratary birds can survive bites from snakes that would kill a horse.

[rayman45]

i never had a salt tank

i had one (47 bow) some one gave to me for free with everything

but i never set it up

[BlackGhostKnifelovr]

awwww no way! i would **** if i got a 47 bow for free lol hell i would be excited for a 20 with all the stuf for salt lol

[rayman45]

i sold it for 500+50 to setitup
it was a reef tank
next time i got to clean the tank ill get pics