View Full Version : Is that a Datnoid he is eating???!!
RockyGoldy
10-25-2006, 12:12 AM
Hi MFKers!!
Shocking Video! Esp the Ending!! Plain cruel!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JlhhKGdvIJc
:irked:
AquataHolic420
10-25-2006, 12:21 AM
I think so.. YIkes
downset21
10-25-2006, 12:23 AM
not a fan
JD7.62
10-25-2006, 12:31 AM
What kind of dat is that? Im pissed cause that would look good in my tank!
On a side note somthing similar to that happened when I had a fish fry. I caught and cleaned a catfish and I fillet much like the guy did in this video. Well I threw the head with spine and tail and guts still attached in a bucket of water and went inside to cook. After cooking, eating, and cleaning I went out to discard the guts and to my disbelief the damn catfish was still alive!!
no i don't think its a datnoid.. at first glance it looked like one in the tank but when it was caught and brought out in the cutting board its stripes don't look like those on any datnoid species, especially when you look at the tail portion and the fish lacks the typical yellow stripe in the snout of datnoids as well.. the body color looks close to an american tiger but the stripes don't match though.. probably a different species of fish..
poor fish though, that's cruel :(
DeLgAdO
10-25-2006, 2:48 AM
what makes it cruel??
is it any different than turning a tilapia into fillet?
RockyGoldy
10-25-2006, 3:04 AM
what makes it cruel??
is it any different than turning a tilapia into fillet?
Thats not my point bro..what I meant is why throw the fish back into the tank for the sake of amusement? the chef could jolly end the fish life after it was fillet....
WyldFya
10-25-2006, 1:58 PM
That is pretty cruel, but it is probably to show how fresh the fish is. Even though it already has a few small chunks taken out of it.
Yikes! That sure did look like a datnoid, but I've always heard that FW fish are never eaten raw, only SW fish.
Gr8KarmaSF
10-25-2006, 2:15 PM
what makes it cruel??
is it any different than turning a tilapia into fillet?
did you see the entire thing mike?:nilly:
the fish was kept alive even thou a big part of it was sliced up!:WHOA:
i also dont think its a dat, its tail end doesnt look like any dat i recognize...i was thinking some sort of saltwater fish perhaps, kinda like a big damsel of some sort. can anybody here translate the vid.? maybe they talk about what kind of fish it is...
yup thats really cruel. like a lot of other things that happen too unfortunately
messiner
10-25-2006, 4:26 PM
def not a dat, head was all wrong
The fish appears to change during the video. The first fish looked more like a Tilapia buttikoferi, but the fish at the end w/ the slice out of it looked very much like a thinbar datnoid. Very strange. Looks fake to me.
redtailfool
10-25-2006, 5:02 PM
Its doesnt look like a datnoid to me. The tail is too light to be a datnoid's .
It is a cruel thing to do.
redtailfool
10-25-2006, 5:07 PM
The head and body stripes did looks like an indo's ... eeps !
looked it up. its a Oplegnathus fasciatus. Anyone know what they're saying in japanese?
http://fishpix.kahaku.go.jp/photos/NR0002/NR0002799AF.jpg
Gr8KarmaSF
10-25-2006, 7:39 PM
B I N G O!!!
:headbang2
rocsorcs
10-26-2006, 5:11 PM
That is very strange. I wouldn't have thought it would have just swam around like that. I would have thought it would be freaking out, and swimming around like my pleco when he is acting retarded. That's what I get for thinking, I guess.
redtailfool
10-26-2006, 5:34 PM
looked it up. its a Oplegnathus fasciatus. Anyone know what they're saying in japanese?
http://fishpix.kahaku.go.jp/photos/NR0002/NR0002799AF.jpg
Good catch sqratch ! So its saltwater...
cichlid savage
10-26-2006, 5:49 PM
Maybe we need a translation to understand fully. But I think they should have just killed the fish.
it is cruel but at the same time its pretty cool
RockyGoldy
10-28-2006, 1:35 AM
looked it up. its a Oplegnathus fasciatus. Anyone know what they're saying in japanese?
http://fishpix.kahaku.go.jp/photos/NR0002/NR0002799AF.jpg
Good info!
So any bros there own this fish? Seems to be super hardy to me after seeing the vid...:irked:
rayman45
10-28-2006, 5:59 AM
1000% not a dat..
how is that crul again?
watch the video carefully. There were two fish in the tank. Now there is only one.
Taz2478
11-02-2006, 1:45 AM
that was cool. I prefer some flames to my fish
watch the video carefully. There were two fish in the tank. Now there is only one.
negative. AFTER the kid gets done eating the 2nd fillet, look at the tank again craig.
You apparently did not watch the video all the way through. ;)
they could show it to be fresh by netting it out the water, and then kill it and serve- it would still be damn fresh. if anything that is done for amusement or as a pointless experiment
benzjamin13
11-02-2006, 12:07 PM
I don't think that's a Dat. Freshwater fish can't be eaten raw because of the bacteria that the fish has unless it's cooked out. I'm amazed that the fish was alive after that. I wonder how long it lived after that? I'm also amazed that the chef was able to get that clean cut fillets without the fish flopping around.
RobD23
11-02-2006, 12:11 PM
no thats not a dat
I don't think that's a Dat. Freshwater fish can't be eaten raw because of the bacteria that the fish has unless it's cooked out. I'm amazed that the fish was alive after that. I wonder how long it lived after that? I'm also amazed that the chef was able to get that clean cut fillets without the fish flopping around.
aren't salmon freshwater as well as salt? They move into freshwater when they spawn or breed right? Surely they would also be able to catch freshwater fish disease.
benzjamin13
11-02-2006, 8:36 PM
aren't salmon freshwater as well as salt? They move into freshwater when they spawn or breed right? Surely they would also be able to catch freshwater fish disease.
Most people aren't aware, sushi quality Salmon are smoked. So they technically been cooked.
Sushi grade salmon (sake) must be caught in SW.
benzjamin13
11-02-2006, 8:42 PM
Sushi grade salmon (sake) must be caught in SW.
or that...I forgot to mention that too :D
Most people aren't aware, sushi quality Salmon are smoked. So they technically been cooked.
yea smoked is pretty much like cooking your steak blue, maybe less. you either eat smoked salmon or have to cook salmon steaks. smoked salmon tastes best and is only salmon ill eat, and thats very rare
freeskierrocket
11-02-2006, 8:50 PM
Nothing some melafix and some aquarium salt wont take care of................:naughty:
.............................whatever............. .A tranlation would be nice though, oh and if that was a real vid and not a fake, then yeah the sushi dude should have chopped that poor fishes head off.............:WHOA:
suckerfish
11-06-2006, 3:49 PM
why's everybody so shocked??? were you expecting something normal like: HUMANE treatment of animals:( :( :( :(
RobD23
11-08-2006, 12:06 AM
nasty