Carib Sea fined for illegal CITES imports

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

davo

Aimara
MFK Member
Jan 9, 2006
17,544
43
132
England
Marine aquarium product manufacturer Carib Sea Inc has been fined $25,000 each (about £13,110) for illegally importing "coral rock" from Haiti.

According to a report from the Palm Beach Post, Carib Sea Inc. and its president Richard Greenfield, both pleaded guilty at a federal court in Miami to a charge of importing more than 19 tonnes of "coral rock" - dead live rock - without a CITES permit.

Betsey Moore, the vice president of Carib Sea said that the rock was mined from land, not from the ocean, and was intended for sale as aquarium decor.

The report claims that Moore said the company was "ecologically minded" and that it made a mistake by not acquiring the correct permit to import the materials.

Moore was reported as saying: "I want to stress this was coral rock and not coral. There's a huge difference. It's perfectly legal with a simple permit, which we've obtained since. This was a very expensive mistake for us. We've been in business for 35 years and have no other marks on our record."

Carib Sea Inc and its president were sentenced to three years probation and the company must pay $25,000 to help support a coral nursery programme in Biscayne National Park. Richard Greenfield, the company's president, was also issued with a $25,000 fine.

Carib Sea Inc has also been ordered to publish notices in three aquarium publications explaining how it violated the requirements of the Convention on International Trade in Endangered Species, the report claims.
 
Glad to see he needs to help the communtiy grow now instead of diminishing it... the oceans lakes ponds...are dying...HELP THE FISH!!
 
WyldFya;572164; said:
Wow, that could hurt their business for quite a while.

50,000 dollars, not likely except for the bad publicity, but if it was just coral rock than they should be fine. It is bad for them, but good for the reef project.
 
To put it into perspective:

They imported 19 tons and were only fined 50 thousand dollars.

I am not sure if this accounts for a loss, but I seriously doubt it. Anyone know what dead coral sells for? Any estimates what they would make per pound? As a rule of thumb, everytime an item trades hands it doubles in price. Since the coral was coming from Hati, I imagine the Hatians were paid pennies on the dollar.
 
RadleyMiller;572183; said:
50,000 dollars, not likely except for the bad publicity, but if it was just coral rock than they should be fine. It is bad for them, but good for the reef project.

Radley, ya beat me by two minutes :D
 
thats a damn shame... Hopefully the poor reputation form now on, will slow down their profits and will somehow even out there disrespect to the coral...BANKRUPT??!?!
 
It won't hurt them. People will still buy there rock regardless, most people don't even know where their rock comes from other then the LFS.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com