Are there any people here who don't desire a larger tank with larger "monster" fish?.

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Eupterus

Gambusia
MFK Member
Dec 11, 2006
934
2
16
Bennington, VT
Like assuming space and money issues aside.
I've decided I like seeing them.......with other people. Oh I've had my phases, at one time I would have wanted a huge tank filled with large plecos.
When I was younger, did I dream about a lot of indoor ponds with whatever huge fish etc...
Of course I was highly amused that when I found MFK:
a) It was real and being done. b) Other people thought exactly the way I did about having huge tanks and fish.

As much as I enjoy them, I don't think I'd want them anymore even if I had the money and my own house.
Part of it is because I've maintained a larger tank long term and partly from what I've read here. Maybe I've even been a MFK keeper if one counts twelve inch fish, which is the largest fish I've ever kept.

It seems these larger fish are far more dependent on aquarium filters to just remain alive. I've noticed posts where "monster" fish have died in a single day over power issues. It seems like more of a life support then having a filter for keeping the water cleaner and reducing water changes.

I'm liking that my fish can survive many disasters and if I want to, they can kept without a filter. So a power outtage doesn't spell instant death for them. This is good because power outtages are not a what if factor, they happen eventually where I am.

I cannot justify spending that kind of money on a mere hobby...To me if you spend vast resources on fishkeeping, it's because it's for earning money. My fish are just pets now, so then I'd rather spend my money elsewhere and I have two careers that I am building up.
And oh yes...reading here has taught me how much even larger tanks with bigger filters can cost. I'm guessing feeding "monster" fish costs a bundle too, though that part hasn't come up here much.

So I started thinking...sure a huge tank with huge fish is awesome, Would I rather have pro graphic tools so I could take my design work further, wouldn't I rather start my own massage room?..Course I am dreaming now how I can place the current tanks at my parent's house into that future massage waiting room.

I am highly amused at married people who don't want a big tank with "monster" fish..I would be like...BRING 'em on in...I'll watch, you care for them...LOL.

Nothing putting people down here, I hope?...just realizing it's not for me and wonder if anyone else is planning to just enjoy the "monsters" in other people's care.
 
When you talk about "vast" resources you need to remember that if you make 30,000 then 20,000 is a lot of money but if you make 100,000 it's not nearly as much money.

I have both, large tanks with large fish and I have large tanks with smaller fish.

I have a 2200 that I'm setting up that will have 3" to 6" fish in it.....

I think that fish keepers go one of a few ways.... they go big, they stay small, they have times that they keep fish and times that they don't or they quit.

No one way is right for everyone and as long as the fish are well cared for it's fine......
 
I've had monster fish before (sunfish) but that whole tank setup was given to me when my parents' friends closed down their restaurant. At the time, I was working at the waikiki aquarium so I got to see prettier, bigger, more active fish than the sunfish so I was never really interested in them. I gave them away and went with a huge school of glass bloodfins instead.

To see a massive school acting as one monster is still something i prefer over seeing a single fish. Besides, having a ton of small fish allows the keeping of other tankmates (such as for maintenance crew) without them being attacked or eaten.
 
Well I don't imagine you'll find many members here who aren't into big tanks and fish, kinda defeats the purpose of membership...

As far as the money goes...lets keep things in perspective. Yes MonsterFishKeeping can get pricey HOWEVER - my father is a private pilot. He spends like 300 a weekend on GAS ALONE (thats a 55 gal tank w/ stand and filter!) to fly planes for fun. I also know and have known a number of people who build and race dirt track cars and dragsters in thier spare time (you KNOW thats not cheap). And that's not even to mention people who collect wine, go to ski resorts, collect firearms, etc. etc.

So in conclusion... yes it can get pricey but in the grand scheme of things...keeping large fish and tanks is NOT that expensive of a hobby.

And for those of us who really love our MONSTER FISH... :)
 
AC?

Plenty of monsters that don't cost an arm and a leg. It's what you enjoy. I love fishkeeping monsters or not, and sometimes I feel like I swing in and out of enthusiasm sometimes, but it's never for long enough for me to think about outing the hobby. When I watch a monster feed or cruise around, or have the small community fish breed makes it worth while. I can think of more expensive hobbies, but no point in spending any money if you dont like what your spending it on...
 
eat the non believer! (pulls out large, hungry fish) seriously man, why did you post this! we all clearly love our monster fish, and dependence on the filter could only mean you overstocked the tank. this is monsterfishkeepers. not neontetrakeepers. If your looking for little fish, you'd best go found neontetrakeepers, and hope we dont sue you.
 
I agree with cenecker. The whole purpose of existence for this website, is for a special niche of aquaria enthusiasts: MONSTER FISH, MONSTER TANKS.

Anything else just belongs over at AC.

Furthermore, only a few species of fish are specially adapted to living in water with low dissolved oxygen. So, even small community fish will die without the aggitation of filtration or powerheads albeit not as quickly.
 
I keep monster fish, but hate maintaining monster tanks, so no, my answer would be a solid no. I'm perfectly happy with 100's and ponds.
In addition, I keep mostly air breathers, which greatly reduces the electricial requirements of each tank. Also less temp-sensitive, so I take a very natural, laid-back, inexpensive route to keeping monster fish. If they're happy, I'm happy.
 
I would also like to say that "Monster" is in the eye of the tankholder. I've heard lots of people say they have a huge tank and then when I ask what size they say 50g. Also who's to say the candiru isn't a monster; anything that swims up someones wang and parasites really should be considered.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com