So what the hell is a gar and what is not one???

Status
Not open for further replies.

Polypterus

Fire Eel
MFK Member
Aug 17, 2005
2,839
8
68
49
Detroit
So just what the hell is a Gar?
And just why is it important to distinguish a Lepisosteid from other fish that may share their common name?

First lets tackle “What is a Gar?”

In our use, we are calling a gar any of the number of fish that belong to the ancient order of fish known as Semionotiformes. Semionotiformes first distinguished themselves from related Neopterygii some 300 or 250 million years ago with a small genus of interesting fish called Obaichthys. Obaichthys was distinctive for it had a different scale arrangement from other Neopterygii. In Obaichthys the scales lacked a then common dentine layer. This was where the Lepisosteidae where born into being. Obaichthys looked much like today’s Atractosteus gars. It was an elongate fish with set back dorsal and anal fins, Caudal fin was Heterocercal, and the nose of the fish was elongate with a set of sharp needle like teeth in two rows on the upper jaw and one in the lower. Unlike modern gar however it had a movable premaxillary.

Gars (Lepisosteidae) then transitioned and evolved out into two genus in the Cretaceous 145 some million years ago. (Atractosteus and Lepisosteus). Both genus where wide spread during much of the late Mesozoic and through the catastrophic extinction that brought in the Cenozoic. Surviving members evolved some 75 MYA and have until today existed unchanged.

Today seven species exist only in North and Central America and on the Island of Cuba. In their glory days of the late Mesozoic, they ranged throughout North America, South America, East Asia, Africa and Europe.

Gar morphology:
Lepisosteids have unique morphology that is quite different from the later evolving and less advanced Teleosts species that have come to take over the earth. As mentioned an important trait is that the scales are unlike other Actinopterygii fishes (Living examples being Polypterids and Sturgeon) and other Neopterygian Fish (Bowfin). Gar scales have a cosmine lower layer that has a dense ganoin layer on top but it lacks the Dentine layer found in previous fish. Other traits are the presence of a spiral valve at the end of the intestine, Vascularized air bladder (that is essentially a “lung”), heterocercal tail, and opisthocoelous (concave posteriorly and convex anteriorly) vertebra.

OK…. That is a gar by definition for the most part..
A definition of Lepisosteidae and what it is that defines them...

Later we define Not gars... provide examples and discuss just why it is important to distinguish them..
 

Polypterus

Fire Eel
MFK Member
Aug 17, 2005
2,839
8
68
49
Detroit
The above two fish look alike but just how alike are they???
They are in fact nothing alike...

Top fish is a Belonid.

Some of these fish are occasionally termed gars. Five families of fishes make up the order Beloniformes: Adrianichthyidae (ricefishes), Belonidae (needlefishes), Scomberesocidae (sauries), Exocoetidae (flyingfishes), and Hemiramphidae (halfbeaks).
(Closely related are also Rainbowfishes)

Oldest known is 50 MYA. These fish are fricking youngin Teleosts and have no relationship to Lepisosteids at all. What they do have in common is elongated jaws with teeth in some genus and that is about it. None have any characteristics of Lepisosteids morphologically or behaviorally. There is nothing about them that that is in anyway comparable. Some of the Needlefish are called “gar” but they are far from being gars.
 

xander

Manjuari
MFK Member
Sep 6, 2007
8,535
57
555
Singapore
great read! so just to be clear, gars have been unchanged for, 75million years?
 

Polypterus

Fire Eel
MFK Member
Aug 17, 2005
2,839
8
68
49
Detroit
Do the above fish look anything alike? Sure they might in some way....

One However is an Atractosteus and the other is a Tetra.. If you tried to keep these fish on equal terms you would kill them both. Both require specific care and neither is in any way related to the other. Gar are not Tetras They are GAR and Lepisosteids should be respected as such...Ctenolucius are tetras and have no traits morphologically or behaviorally with an Atractosteus or any lepisosteid for that matter. The only thing they have in common is the retarded Common name "Rocket gar"

I just love that pic by Hristo it shows a Ctenolucius Hujeta better than any other pic...This guy takes some awesome pics..
 

Raul-7

Gambusia
MFK Member
Apr 6, 2007
167
1
18
Lomita, CA
Polypterus;1403464; said:
I just love that pic by Hristo it shows a Ctenolucius Hujeta better than any other pic...This guy takes some awesome pics..
I agree. He's a member over at APC and his pictures are beyond incredible.
 

SimonL

Fire Eel
MFK Member
Oct 23, 2005
3,213
9
68
Ontario, Canada
Awesome thread Polypterus! I just exiled all euteleostei fish from my collection...Gotta stick with Mesozoic fish....

Oldest known is 50 MYA. These fish are fricking youngin Teleosts
Although substantially "younger" than holosteans (is holostean still valid?), Characins must have had a Jurassic origin, given that they are found in both South America and Africa. Therefore they must have existed in Gondwana before the seperation of the continents...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
zoomed.com
hikariusa.com
aqaimports.com
Store