tips for breaking rays to new foods

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nic

Nic

Peacock Bass
MFK Member
Oct 8, 2005
15,790
14
119
outside philly
Since this comes up pretty often figure a straight thread would be good... these are some methods ive used to break rays to other foods... add yours as well...

soaking freeze dried krill in the black worm goo works great for retics...

grinding pellets up and stuffing worms with them or shrimps...

starving for up to a week ( you know your rays so what ever makes you comfortable)

i will also make my ray food up the night before and allow smelts or silver sides to marinate with shrimps to get rays on them...

clams, cockles,and mussels all were done via starve method and marinate...

add your methods and maybe it can be a sticky for nobody to look at in the future...:ROFL:
 
Gr8KarmaSF

Gr8KarmaSF

Administrator
Staff member
Administrator
MFK Member
Jul 23, 2005
22,870
211
697
Quarantine Tank
Nic;1779784; said:
this will probably be my last post here as well....
Click to expand...
NOOOOO!!!

Like I said, dont let one members misperception of you turn you away from posting. You have so much knowledge that its your responsibility as a fish and ray keeper to share it with others. Why would you let one person stop you from helping others? Think of all the rays, fish, and people that would benefit from your experiences.

Unless you feel that this person really knows you well enough to judge you then you should even care what this person thinks?

Like I tell my students, somebody will always call you names you just have to ignore them. Hence simply put this person on your ignore list. You are a well respected member here and it would be ashame if you stopped posting...
 
  • Like
Reactions: Matteus
A

andersp90

Fire Eel
MFK Member
Apr 11, 2007
1,666
5
68
Denmark
Nic;1779784; said:
Since this comes up pretty often figure a straight thread would be good... these are some methods ive used to break rays to other foods... add yours as well...

soaking freeze dried krill in the black worm goo works great for retics...

grinding pellets up and stuffing worms with them or shrimps...

starving for up to a week ( you know your rays so what ever makes you comfortable)

i will also make my ray food up the night before and allow smelts or silver sides to marinate with shrimps to get rays on them...

clams, cockles,and mussels all were done via starve method and marinate...

add your methods and maybe it can be a sticky for nobody to look at in the future...:ROFL:
Click to expand...
:iagree: though i just mix the new food with bloodworms (we dont have blackworms here in Denmark).. They will take new foods after a week or so with this method.. :)

Also, i want your Msn before you go anywhere, we have lots of knowledge to share (Pm me if so)..!

Though i think you should stay here, you are one of the best ray keepers on this forum (if not the best)..!
 
N

needycowgirl

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Oct 14, 2007
112
0
0
Spokane WA
Patience patience patience! I tried the soaking method, I tried the starve method, I think I tried every method I found on here. I just kept being persitant and WALLA! Both my Retics now eat black worm (duh), red wigglers, krill and finally earthworm....Even tho Bruce still eats it with reluctance. But he eats it.

So I say try everything and be patient!!!!!
 
R

Rosewood022

Candiru
MFK Member
Feb 17, 2006
308
1
48
45
Troy, MI
Good info Nic. I've really only used the starving method. I'm going to try soaking. I've got a few rays that are picky and want them to eat other things.

Thanks for the tips. Don't quit posting either.

Pat
Amazon Stingrays
 
A

ajb1971

Gambusia
MFK Member
May 20, 2005
334
0
16
53
Lowell, MA
I've found when keeping rays with other rays, they're more likely to trying new foods (must be a competition thing) rather than a solo ray.
Wild caught rays are more complicated to get on prepared foods, but I find black worms are a great start, then cut earth worms, then shrimp cut to a size (easily for the ray to inhale) marinated in cut-up earth worms. Then from there, once the ray has been eating well and has fatten up, I'll use a starvation method up to 3 days but, like I said, if in groups, they usually try to steal each other's food and will end up eating it.
With rays, I say, "If they nibbled it, they will eat it---eventually"
 
T

tank125

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Apr 20, 2005
896
0
0
40
Connecticut
ajb1971;1780666; said:
I've found when keeping rays with other rays, they're more likely to trying new foods (must be a competition thing) rather than a solo ray.
Wild caught rays are more complicated to get on prepared foods, but I find black worms are a great start, then cut earth worms, then shrimp cut to a size (easily for the ray to inhale) marinated in cut-up earth worms. Then from there, once the ray has been eating well and has fatten up, I'll use a starvation method up to 3 days but, like I said, if in groups, they usually try to steal each other's food and will end up eating it.
With rays, I say, "If they nibbled it, they will eat it---eventually"
Click to expand...
Good Points!

I want empathize the importance of first finding a food that your ray likes and feeding heavily for days/weeks to get good weight on. If you are not used to rays you will be amazed at how much their hunger drive can change from the first few days to the month later. When the ray is greedy and begging for food and aggressive with food, that is when I like to start offering other foods to vary the diet. I utilize the methods mentioned in this thread: soaking, chopping into small bits, "starving"
 
vamptrev

vamptrev

Silver Tier VIP
MFK Member
Apr 23, 2007
8,227
863
924
Chesterfield MI
tank125;1780920; said:
Good Points!

I want empathize the importance of first finding a food that your ray likes and feeding heavily for days/weeks to get good weight on. If you are not used to rays you will be amazed at how much their hunger drive can change from the first few days to the month later. When the ray is greedy and begging for food and aggressive with food, that is when I like to start offering other foods to vary the diet. I utilize the methods mentioned in this thread: soaking, chopping into small bits, "starving"
Click to expand...
very good point on getting the ray fat and healthy first. i hear alot of people that try to get their fish off of live foods dont bother to get them healthy b4 they starve them.

also when i had a retic, he wouldnt eat anything but blackworms. i then put in 2 motoros with him and he instantly took to earthworms, shrimp, and smelt.
 
Nic

Nic

Peacock Bass
MFK Member
Oct 8, 2005
15,790
14
119
outside philly
forgot to add ray should be fat and healthy first.... great point thanks for adding it.....
 
keepinfish

keepinfish

Potamotrygon
MFK Member
Jun 29, 2007
7,386
658
174
45
In God We Trust
one of my rays took pellets the fist time i fed, the other one took about a week of feeding pellets for her to be interested, i tried to cut back that week from feeding prepared foods. Then she got tired of seeing the male full and started eating them.
Seemed pretty easy. Not all my fish but my eel will eat massivore, shrimp pellets, or sinking gold.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
zoomed.com
hikariusa.com
aqaimports.com
Store
Top Bottom