Simplest way to cycle a tank for beginners

This question isn't really for me but more for my customers. I work at a LFS and people new to fish-keeping come in frequently. So the question with cycling comes up quite often, of course. Trying to explain how to cycle a tank is like speaking another language to them and it's pretty obvious with the look of overwhelm on their faces. I try to explain the process and options to them as simply as possible and even offer to test their water weekly to tell them where they're at in their cycle.

So here's my question; what is the most SIMPLE way to do a fish-less cycle in your opinions? I personally know how to cycle a tank without fish and have done quite a few myself, but the moment I start trying to explain adding bacteria and ammonia, they're eyes glaze over and they don't get it. SO, I'd love to hear if any of you have reasonable solutions for beginners...being aware that some of these people want fast results with little work. My job is essentially trying to get them to do as much of the "right thing" as possible and hope they listen.

We sell Nitromax and Stability at my work. I have personal experience with Stability and actually really like the product, occasionally adding it into my established tanks a few times a year still. There are a few other products, but these would be the two products I could recommend since I've had customers getting good results with Nitromax as well. Is it possible to cycle a tank with JUST one of these bacteria without fussing with ammonia? Adding more than one thing to the tank is usually where I lose them, so just having one step (besides dechlorinator) with an average of 2-3 weeks of cycling would be ideal. Stability mentions being able to add fish at some point to the tank, wouldn't it be more problematic trying to add fish in the middle of a cycle vs. a fish in the beginning acclimating to the spikes?

Cycling always seemed so easy for myself until I had to start trying to simplify and "dummy proof" it for others.

I have given them some of the gravel from our tanks before, but that's not enough to build a colony enough to cycle it I thought. 6-8 weeks is definitely not a practical thing to have the average/beginner fish keeper, it's hard enough to make them wait 2 weeks as it is. For the experienced keeper, who knows that short cuts aren't always the best sure....but that would be near impossible to try to tell a family and their kid that they can't put their new fish in for 2 months. I don't care about trying to get them to buy unnecessary products, I just care about trying to make it as easy and as fool proof as possible. Ammonia seems to freak people out honestly, I don't understand why. I know these bacteria DO work though, I've cycled with and without Stability, and with and without fish, and there is definitely a difference. I just wonder if just the bacteria would suffice or at least the bacteria and fish flake. I believe I read that nitromax has some sort of way that it maintains in your tank, but I need to sit down and read the label on it again since I don't personally use it at home.

skjl47 said:

[/B]

Hello; This is my thought as well. Give them some mature media in water along with a starter fish or two. If you have access to some sort of mesh bag the media could be placed in the mesh bag and suspended in the new tank setup.
Perhaps make slices of sponge filter material. I did this some time ago. Found a suitable sponge material at wal-mart. I cut it to fit on an old sponge filter base. It is thin enough to have a double layer on one base. I can now peel one layer off if I need to seed a new setup.

Click to expand...

hmm, I like this idea actually. Might be better than constantly taking out our gravel for people. I've done the with fish cycle, that's an easy one to explain; but people don't understand that sometimes you can lose a fish during the cycle and they turn around and blame us for the death. It hasn't really happened to me yet working here, but I have worked in plenty of fish stores to know people don't understand that cycling can be tough on even hardy fish.

skjl47 said:

hello; It will depend on the load of ammonia. If they insist on filling the tank with a lot of fish right away, then the bb on a sample of media will not be able to handle that load. A small amount of seeded media should balance a new tank with a few fish. The bb should multiply quickly enough to balance out if new fish are added a few at a time.

Click to expand...

right, which is what I normally tell them to do when they start adding fish regardless. Maybe I've been too overly cautious and babying my customers. I don't really ever get any complaints about losses and am always complimented on the care I give them, but I guess I could just recommend established media and just skipping the fish-less cycle altogether. The bacteria products I used advertise that you can add fish immediately, would it suffice if we didn't have any media to give them? Some of our tanks have extra buffers or brackish salts so if someone came on a day I was going through my cleaning fest on the none buffered tanks, I'm concerned the media wouldn't have enough good stuff in it for them.