There are a few species known as eye biters, and they are African cichlids.
The most common is Dimidiochromis compressiceps, they do not usually take out other fishes eyes if well fed, and get quite beautiful, and fairly slow growers.
But because you are posting in the new world cichlid area, I'm guessing you want to put it with NWs, and while South American cichlids may not be a problem, but they may not able to deal with some Central American aggressiveness.