Black Diamond and Black beauty are coal slag. The MSDS for coal slag makes me feel like I'd not want it in a tank.
Here is what "Coal Slag" is. It's not a manufactured product, it's a waste product with a varying partical size and chemical composition.
Also, the "sharpness" of each batch is completely random. Some is more smooth, some has long strands of glass. I'd not put it in with fish that sift sand. It's basically just pulvarised glass in texture, sorted by partical size.
3. Composition / Information on Ingredients
MSDS # 68476-96-0
Coal, slag
Constituents
CAS Percent
Silicon dioxide 41-53
Iron oxide 7-31
Aluminum oxide 17-25
Calcium oxide 3-15
Magnesium oxide 0-4
Potassium Oxide 0-3