Pygo confusion

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

caribemob

Piranha
MFK Member
Feb 24, 2008
2,413
46
81
philadelphia
I have a 125gal ready to put pygo's in, however I want to start a mixed shoal of wild reds, ternetzi's, super reds, I can find wild reds and super reds but can't find terns and caribe. I wanted to put 3 of each with like a total of nine all together. Can anyone tell me where to find the other species and if not should I start stocking with wild reds and super reds and just wait till somebody has the rare ones in stock. Also I need them to be no bigger than three inches for starters.
 
wild reds and super reds are the same, just how different vendors call them, same goes to snake skin reds.
maybe a slow start for caribe season or we just don't have a caribe season this year..
I don't see terns on sale that often and usually are in pretty big size.
 
They do not have them currently but Aquascapeonline should have them this summer I was told I would get tgheir number and call them to see when they will have back in stock
 
jp80911;3132620; said:
wild reds and super reds are the same, just how different vendors call them, same goes to snake skin reds.
maybe a slow start for caribe season or we just don't have a caribe season this year..
I don't see terns on sale that often and usually are in pretty big size.

Actually, a wild red and a super red are different. A super red come from a curtain part of the river (i forget which part) and are secluded to that specific part. As reds are found throughout.......
 
Timmy;3132811; said:
Actually, a wild red and a super red are different. A super red come from a curtain part of the river (i forget which part) and are secluded to that specific part. As reds are found throughout.......

Technically wild red and super red are the same, as wild reds are wild caught and super reds are also wild caught, so wild red can be super red, it's all up to how the dealer wants to call them.
Super red is the common name used for the fish from Peru, but as dealer can call them whatever they want and you won't really know where it came from unless you put the fish out of the river yourself.

In the end, what I was trying to say is that they are all pygo. nattereri, there's no difference between them other than how they color when they were pull out of the river.

same applies to Terns, just a different color morph of pygocentrus nattereri.

from OPEFE
http://opefe.com/nattereri.html

COMMENTS ABOUT SUPER REDS OR SNAKESKIN Pygocentrus nattereri BY FRANK MAGALLANES

The common name Super Red is meaningless for any specific P. nattereri since these fish can be highly colored in dark red or reddish-orange within its range. The common name has been applied to fish from Peru. A look at the geographical forms of P. nattereri can show that some are more brilliant than others. This color can also be lost during the fishes growth in your aquarium or a dealer's tank as the fish matures. The dealer who coined that name for his fish was probably unaware (at the time) this name could apply to a number of species. It is a relatively new name in the piranha hobby and it is indeed foolish to just attach it to just one locality of P. nattereri.

As for the reticulated P. nattereri, this feature is found on some but not all of the fishes from the middle Amazon. If one wanted to call this a Snakeskin, then that would be fine for a common name so long as the person understands that feature is eventually lost behind the brilliant scales. For some unknown reason, this name was eventually grouped with Super Red. Again its value is a minor concern. The real value in these wild fishes is the fact they are wild and can replenish a diminished gene pool if you are into breeding piranhas. Some people collect solely for their beauty (which is what I do). Others because they are "wild" and in that there is value.

The important thing for everyone to remember is BE INFORMED and don't blame dealers if they use a common name. It's up to you, the consumer, to know the difference.

http://opefe.com/nattereri_2.html
 
I talked to pedro and he said caribes might not be in till after the summer. This truly sucks, I guess I will just get wild reds because nothing else is in stock. George at shark aquarium has everything but there all 6 and 7 inches and I want to start at least at 4 inches orsmaller. So iguess I willget ten wild reds then I don't want captive bred they are too skittish for me
 
Wild reds aren't much less skittish IMO. Whether you wait or not is up to you. I do think you're fine just go ahead and ordering your reds. You can always get caribe/terns close to the same size your reds get to later. I know I got small terns (2-3") from aquascape a couple years ago.
 
yeah im going to get a mix of wild reds and super reds total of 6 and when tt i'm he more exotic pygos are in stock i will def grab like 4 more terns and caribe so my shoAL will be like 10 0r 11 in my 125 than later im going to upgrade them to my 300 gal that i'm getting in like december:headbang2
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com