How's this for quiet? Video of my Beananimal Overflow, 190g

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

jcardona1

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Jun 5, 2007
11,491
40
0
43
South of Heaven
Gave the the system a test run so I took a quick video to show off how super quiet this thing is!!!! I love it! This is with one 1000gph pump. A second 1000gph pump will be added also.

Enjoy!

[YT]ve9sxd4tlf8[/YT]

 
Thanks guys, should do nicely in the living room :headbang2
 
Can you show how the intake pipes enter the sump and where they are relative to the sump's water level? (To see how you keep that part quiet too)

Looks like the water line is slightly below the rim of the tank... could you have set it to be higher if you wanted? I'm a little surprised the overflow has a lower water level. guess I would've expected it to be pretty close to leveled off there, much closer to the emergency drain.

Is your middle one the main intake? Do it and the right side one both have water flowing through them equally? Or does that middle one only get used if the water reaches up to the 1/4" tube and creates a siphon? The way I understood it from the original was that only one was in use, but watching it with water in it and seeing both submerged it makes me wonder. (Also, weren't his all on the same height? Your middle one is higher, right?)
 
below

DaveB;4933787; said:
Can you show how the intake pipes enter the sump and where they are relative to the sump's water level? (To see how you keep that part quiet too) Don't have any pics at the moment, but these pipes are 1-2" below the sump's water level, to avoid any splashing sound.

Looks like the water line is slightly below the rim of the tank... could you have set it to be higher if you wanted? I'm a little surprised the overflow has a lower water level. guess I would've expected it to be pretty close to leveled off there, much closer to the emergency drain. Yes, it could be made higher. This depends on the height of the overflow box. I didn't want the water level so high that it would touch the bottom panes of the bracing, so gave myself a little room to spare. The level in the box (and overall noise) is controlled by the valve on the main drain line, the one on the far right.

Is your middle one the main intake? Do it and the right side one both have water flowing through them equally? Or does that middle one only get used if the water reaches up to the 1/4" tube and creates a siphon? The way I understood it from the original was that only one was in use, but watching it with water in it and seeing both submerged it makes me wonder. (Also, weren't his all on the same height? Your middle one is higher, right?) Main drain is the one on the right, open channel pipe is middle, emergency on left. The main drain on the right is the full siphon, which handles most of the flow. Full siphons handle a lot of flow and are silent, because no air is in the pipe. The middle pipe is 1/4" higher, and handling a small amount of spillover, because the main drain is partially closed off. This small amount of spillover clings to walls of the pipe, and quietly goes down to the sump. The middle drain will convert to a full siphon if and only if the water level reaches the 1/4" tube.
 
:)
 
What would happen if you didn't have an overflow box? If the intakes were just visible in the back of the tank, or even possibly drilled and inserted from the top? (Doing it that way would require a wonky looking sideways S shaped pipe for the emergency one to be face up, of course.) Could the flow all be equalized while keeping the water level almost all the way up to the top of an acrylic tank without actually having an overflow box?

Obviously the intakes themselves would need to be up higher; the emergency one would basically need to be almost touching the top of the tank. Maybe that's what throws the whole idea off?

Note that I'm asking this question as an obvious novice who doesn't understand why the water level in the overflow above doesn't settle itself at the same level as what's in the tank. In other words, don't make fun of me :)
 
It should work. I'm pretty sure I've seen this before too. Lots of people do this with Herbie setups. The main reason for having an overflow box is surface skimming. Without an overflox box, the elbows will be drawing water a few inches below the surface, not from the surface. So you could get that unsightly surface scum, and have nothing to remove it...
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com