Which Gar Species Do I Have Exactly?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Sarcosuchus

Candiru
MFK Member
Oct 28, 2006
758
9
48
Everywhere
Hello there, the day before yesterday I was at the nearest LFS standing between three Gar species. One was what I believe a Shortnose Gar swimming with a two short and broad snouted Gars. They were all juveniles.

On the other side of the aquarium was a nice patterned Gar which I assumed was either a Florida Gar or a Spotted Gar. It was a juvenile as well, about 5 to 6 inches long. I wanted to choose between the broad and short snouted and the spotted type Gar although I had no idea which one was exactly the Spotted Gar as the broad and short snouted had spots all over its body and fins as well except on top of its body which was just dark.

Well so it's clear I am new to Gar, due to the attraction I had to that broad and short snouted Gar I baught it! such an awesome snout like the Saltwater Crocodile. The fish is a beauty, about 5 inches long and it was great to see it cruising near the surface like a Crocodile and BAMM!! lightning fast striking at feeders, and those teeth..impressive. Still unsure what species it was exactly that I asked a fish forum and was told that it's the Alligator Gar!:eek: was I not shocked ( Pictures below, or is it the hybrid Crocodile Gar? ). All the ones responded said it was the Alligator Gar.

Although I was very attracted, I had to rush to the LFS and tell the shopkeeper about my situation ( I can't handle it as I live in an apartment ), he agreed to trade with what I believe is a Florida or Spotted Gar ( pictures below ). I think it's a Florida Gar, isn't it?

post-10310-1161917382.jpg

post-10310-1161917414.jpg

post-10310-1161950844.jpg

post-10310-1161950869.jpg
 
i know im not a expert in gar :D but i think the third and last pics is a spottedgar

c.jpg


by the way welcome here:)
 
Cool, so that is the Alligator Gar that grows to 10 feet in the wild? Why the pictures of them that I see are almost or often without any spots? Check out these pictures below I found online, an Alligator Gar right? Unbelievable to see how from this lean and nicely patterned appearance they literally become a monstrous fish that we can see in the following picture looking like a different species.

So the other is a Spotted Gar huh? How do you tell that? Because one had said it's the Florida Gar. So it's confusing, I know both Florida and Spotted Gars have spots, Florida Gar's throat has no scales unlike the Spotted Gar's. This one's throat is plain black and looking like a soft skin. Last night when he caught a big feeder the skin stretched that it became transparent showing the feeder inside.

24408.jpg

24409.jpg

24410.jpg

24411.jpg

alligator_gar.jpg
 
The bottom one is strange, it looks just like a tropical gar, but seems to have a very narrow snout like a lepisosteus.
 
rumblesushi;557487; said:
The bottom one is strange, it looks just like a tropical gar, but seems to have a very narrow snout like a lepisosteus.

Younger Tropicus have fairly narrow and long snouts for an Atractosteus.
the angle of the photo could also be exagerating the fish.

tropical3.jpg
 
Man, a Tropical Gar? Here are pictures of the Tropical Gar from Primitivefish.com, wow they do look similar to mine!

TGarbig2a.jpg

TGarsml1a.jpg

TGarsml2a.jpg

TRtgarpair.jpg
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com