Geophagus salt sensitive?

[BMac91]

Got a few new Geos and they are infested with ich. Raised temp to 86.2 and was going to add salt like I typically would, but I stumbled across some conflicting info stating Geos are very sensitive to salt? Is this true?

I was going to add 1 teaspoon per gal, but like I said was a little skeptical after reading some conflicting info.

 

[Frank Castle]

Got a few new Geos and they are infested with ich. Raised temp to 86.2 and was going to add salt like I typically would, but I stumbled across some conflicting info stating Geos are very sensitive to salt? Is this true?

I was going to add 1 teaspoon per gal, but like I said was a little skeptical after reading some conflicting info.

not sure which Geos you're talking about, but I have Brasiliensis, "Abalios/Dicrozoster" and Gymnogeophagus balzanii and they are not sensitive to it at all.....as a matter of fact, I have gone from doing 1TBSP per 10 gallons in their tanks 24/7 - 365 to about 1 per 7.5 gallons.....so say instead of 6 for 30 gallons, i'm doing more like 8 for 30 gallons. Everything is all fine and dandy and they are looking and acting healthier than ever. The random occasional torn fin on any of my fish heals within 48 hours or so, even a more serious one (recently my 2 RTMs had an argument and the smaller one had a quite a bit of caudal chewed off) - 72 hours at most.

Salt is ******* great, use the hell out of it. I have been for years on all fish, regardless of family or gena or whatever

 

[BMac91]

Yeah I have Abalios and some Dicros with it. Thanks Frank, will go ahead and get it going!

 

[tlindsey]

Got a few new Geos and they are infested with ich. Raised temp to 86.2 and was going to add salt like I typically would, but I stumbled across some conflicting info stating Geos are very sensitive to salt? Is this true?

I was going to add 1 teaspoon per gal, but like I said was a little skeptical after reading some conflicting info.

Just be careful if you have scale less fish like corydoras, or loaches.

 

[Frank Castle]

Just be careful if you have scale less fish like corydoras, or loaches.

would you be surprised if I said "I'm not"? I think Corys and Hoplos are one of the few cats that DO have scales, don't they? They sure look like they have a split row going down them

Don't forget, our 3 biggest native cats have all been found in brackish water, Channel cats even full marine in some places like Indian River, FL and Mosquito Lagoon. I'm starting to really question how sensitive scaleless fish are tbh, and might there have been some other unknown factor contributing to this conclusion, perhaps. Our native cats are definitely 100% scaleless

All of my bottom-feeders receive the same dose of salt as my cichlids do - Cats, Plecos, "Sharks", Eels, you name it

 

[duanes]

The Geophagus braziliensus clade can sometimes be found entering brackish river estuaries in southern Brazil, so no problem with those. The other species, I can't speak to.

 

[tlindsey]

would you be surprised if I said "I'm not"? I think Corys and Hoplos are one of the few cats that DO have scales, don't they? They sure look like they have a split row going down them

Don't forget, our 3 biggest native cats have all been found in brackish water, Channel cats even full marine in some places like Indian River, FL and Mosquito Lagoon. I'm starting to really question how sensitive scaleless fish are tbh, and might there have been some other unknown factor contributing to this conclusion, perhaps. Our native cats are definitely 100% scaleless

All of my bottom-feeders receive the same dose of salt as my cichlids do - Cats, Plecos, "Sharks", Eels, you name it

Maybe my case was an isolated one, lost both loaches , cories in the same aquarium. Was treating for out break of ich added salt the loaches, and cories seem to excrete slime coat excessively.

 

[tlindsey]

I apologize didn't mean to derail thread.

 

[Frank Castle]

I apologize didn't mean to derail thread.

derail? Everything looks relevant to me

 

[BMac91]

No worries, no scaleless fish in this tank. Only Geos and a couple Buenos Aires Tetras.