Holes/Blemishes on Kelberi Gills

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Safi'jiiva

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Mar 3, 2021
11
1
8
25
Have you tested your water?
Yes
If yes, what is your ammonia?
1ppm
If yes, what is your nitrite?
0ppm
If yes, what is your nitrate?
100+ ppm
If I did not test my water...
  1. ...I recognize that I will likely be asked to do a test, and that water tests are critical for solving freshwater health problems.
Do you do water changes?
Yes
What percentage of water do you change?
21-30%
How frequently do you change your water?
Every week
If I do not change my water...
  1. ...I recognize that I will likely be recommended to do a water change, and water changes are critical for preventing future freshwater health problems.
Hi there. I have a 17" Kelberi in a 1000g aquarium. I've been away at university for the past month-ish and left the tank in the care of my parents.
I've told them what to do while I'm gone and been talking to them about how to do maintenance on this tank.
Long story short I come home to a disaster. Debris everywhere, Nitrates through the roof, and about 1ppm of ammonia...
I've spent all day cleaning the tank, and constantly kept discovering new issues.
My pumps ****ed somehow, filter won't backwash right, and now there's these holes in the hill plates of my absolute favorite fish.
Pictures of them below.
Is this ammonia burn or an infection of some sort? Or both?
His gills aren't reddened, but I have never seen these blemishes, he's also the only fish with this issue.
My Shovelnose is fine, my Severum is fine, my Gars are fine. Just the Kelberi has this issue.
His breathing isn't very labored, and he's not flashing and scratching.
He's also got his appetite and doesn't fight with anybody. He also isn't skittish and I haven't introduce a new fish in this tank for over a year.
Somebody please help me, I cannot find any good info via Google and I've not encountered ammonia issues since beginning the hobby.

Also it would let my put my water change frequency in currently, but I usually do 25% twice a week on this tank, and kept my parameters at 0ppm Ammonia, 0ppm Nitrite, and less than 30ppm Nitrate.

I can provide more photos if these aren't good enough. I took an underside photo of his gills in case anybody wanted to see that. Holes are on both sides on his gill plates.

PXL_20211005_190422479.jpg

PXL_20211005_190354880.jpg

PXL_20211005_183843246.jpg

PXL_20211005_183834143.jpg

PXL_20211005_183806408.MP.jpg
 
Little hard to make out but could be hith from poor water conditions. Keep the nitrates down below 20ppm. Feed hex shield. Monitor.
 
Little hard to make out but could be hith from poor water conditions. Keep the nitrates down below 20ppm. Feed hex shield. Monitor.
I was worried it could be HITH, I admit I do not know much at all about the disease. If it is HITH then my question is how do I treat it? There's no way I can quarantine him right now, and I have no idea what meds to get or where to get them. If it is HITH does it look really bad or did I catch it in time? I'm not noticing holes anywhere else but the sides of the gills.
 
I was worried it could be HITH, I admit I do not know much at all about the disease. If it is HITH then my question is how do I treat it? There's no way I can quarantine him right now, and I have no idea what meds to get or where to get them. If it is HITH does it look really bad or did I catch it in time? I'm not noticing holes anywhere else but the sides of the gills.
Looks like early hith to me. Treat the underlying cause which was the bad water. Since corrected it should hopefully heal up. Doesn’t look bad.
 
Looks like early hith to me. Treat the underlying cause which was the bad water. Since corrected it should hopefully heal up. Doesn’t look bad.
So get the tank back to normal and it'll be okay? That's a major relief. Will Prime help him any? Since it nullifies the effects of ammonia.
 
So get the tank back to normal and it'll be okay? That's a major relief. Will Prime help him any? Since it nullifies the effects of ammonia.
It’ll help bind it and make it inactive. Just keep up with the water changes.
 
No one can tell you for sure if it'll stop, but usually fish in clean water with low to no nitrate and other proper parameters will help to stop or reduce effects of hith. I've taken tangs with bad hlle and put them in clean water with proper care/feeding and they have rebounded well.
 
No one can tell you for sure if it'll stop, but usually fish in clean water with low to no nitrate and other proper parameters will help to stop or reduce effects of hith. I've taken tangs with bad hlle and put them in clean water with proper care/feeding and they have rebounded well.
I expect like most things in the hobby it's one step at a time. I'll be home every day to get the tank back to normal and monitor him. How long could it take for hlle to heal? If it's been a while without improvement or gets worse I'll be back on here for sure.
 
Looks like we have similar gold kels.
My female kel has problems with lesions on her face. Probably has had it for almost a year. Otherwise vibrant and healthy. My male kel can sometimes get pits. Both conditions occur at the sensory pits are are most likely related to HITH.
Both my kels get lots of vitamins and garlic.
I know for sure that water and filter must be very clean for these fish. Large water changes and basically pristine sump filter.
Very clean substrate also.
My water is pretty hard and somtimes I wonder if it has caused or leaded to this problem with the female.
She only has it on one side of the face. Seems to be healing but very very slowly. Not getting worse.
If your fish are flashing treating with salt will help.
If the problem gets worse you will probably need to medicate.
Personally I hate to medicate. Much rather try to solve with clean fresh water and vitamins/ garlic.
BTW, I use Safe. Much cheaper than Prime.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
So get the tank back to normal and it'll be okay? That's a major relief. Will Prime help him any? Since it nullifies the effects of ammonia.
The open areas don’t look bad. Don’t have much of an eroded look to it. As the others have mentioned whether it’ll get better is hard to say. Seen small and shallow areas recover but some remanent left behind. Others spots not so much. Keep up the water changes and if not better then consider the hex shield. Best of luck.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com