I keep my house at 66 F all year. I keep my water at 77-78 F I have 2 125's and I only use one heater at a time now and I have been using 1 Ebo Jager 250 or 1 Theo 400w and they all keep the water just the same.
I would go with 2 -200 watt stealths on a single thermostat/ heat controller that way they last longer and one of them does not end up doing a majority of the work. Me and zenzo had a big discussion about this. Its especially important with stealths because they have no light for when they are turned on.