5 star vs Jag?

[blurock]

Alright, so I know there are two or three threads for Five Star Generals right now, and i've been posting in one of them, but a new question has arisen in my little head...

If I put a 4 or 5" Five Star in with a 7" Jag do you think they would be ok together? I know 5stars are really aggressive, but would the size difference chill them out a bit? Or would the 5 star beat the jag up anyway?

 

[cornbread_5]

what is the size of the tank you are trying to try this in

 

[blurock]

either a 55 or 75... would probably start in a 55 and go to the 75 when those inhabitants outgrow it...

 

[cornbread_5]

i think its a fight to the death , it a toss up on who will win but my moneys on the five star but if u do try it make sure you got plenty of hiding places

 

[gran charismo]

by the time the jag outgrows the 55 it would beat the 5 star

 

[xiahaolong168]

i think the 5 star will kill the jag in a 55

 

[enjoy fatboy]

depends
is the jag agressive yet?
my jag i had before killed an RD and the rd was nuts
so idk

 

[cornbread_5]

yeah that does depend how aggressive is your jag and has it always been by itself or have it had tankmates

 

[mike dunagan]

so pretty much one will die, not a good plan? This what everyone is saying?