A lil help plz

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

JPCHAOS

Jack Dempsey
MFK Member
Nov 1, 2012
161
0
31
post falls, id
Can some one plz explain how to sex a catfish or just fish in general lol
Here's a pic of the lil guy or gal in question. uploadfromtaptalk1354763209409.jpg

Sent from my HTC One X using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
Looks like a baby electric catfish. These guys will get pretty big and its virtually impossible to sex a cat this size.
 
Looks like a baby electric catfish. These guys will get pretty big and its virtually impossible to sex a cat this size.

It is indeed a baby e-cat, yes i know they get big hes gettin a 120 to himself soon. So how do u sex them wat do u look for, if i post a pic of an adult will u explain a lil?
Sent from my HTC One X using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
 
^^What he said. These cats can't be reliably sexed with anything other than a scope. The only method I've heard of is to have a batch of similar-age, similar-fed individuals and to pick out the plumpest (considered as female due to ovaries displacing more internal space than testes) and leanest (considered male) specimens. Several scientific studies can be cited that describe a possible sexual dimorphism in ecats by way of differences in the electrical output signal wavelengths of mature specimens during their natural breeding season. But, there are many disagreements in these papers. Plus, it wouldn't be feasable to try duplicating the lab setups on a hobbyist level.
These cats are thought to be bank mud-cave spawners by some and under-log/rock spawners by others. There's never been a successful spawning in captivity.
 
http://www.planetcatfish.com/catelog/species.php?species_id=109 as the datasheet says "Males are more slender" - that's all you can go by; very subjective. Oddball gave an excellent answer.

I was actually looking into a way to sex catfish a while back. :) seems you can get an home ultrasound kit for around $4,000. Plugs right into your laptop or desktop computer. Might even be an app for iphone by now lol. So yeah, apparently this is a really good way to sex catfish and some of the hatcheries have started using them as well now that the price is dropping. Exploratory surgery use to be used as well. Catfish(most species) have very little sexual dimorphism. Very extremely hard to sex non the less. Good luck. :) Just remember that even females will become slimmer if they go on a food strike. This skinny vs. fat method is mainly used when the female becomes full of eggs, and you'd need to keep them under ideal conditions for spawning for that to occur. Some species of catfish would require recreating seasonal changes that occur naturally in the wild to get the occyte developement to even happen. :) I'd love to see someone spawn some ecats!!!!
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com