Am I being stupid?

[Terryallen]

Ok, before I begin, I believe I already know the answer.....NO!
But eitherway, I have 3 red bellies. Their about 4 inches already in the yr I have gotton them. Their in a 70 gallon tank. And their doing great!
My brother ask me to tale his shark off of him. Its not even a yr old. ( its just a regular grey amd black one). Would it be stupoid to put it in the tank with the red bellies? Would it live?

 

[knifegill]

The cyprinid would be dinner. And your piranhas would thank you if it was healthy and gut-loaded.

 

[Terryallen]

Thank you

 

[Otherone]

If your RBP's have only grown to 4" in a year I'd say they are starving. Take the shark to a fish store or list on craigslist and study the Piranha nutrtional guide on this forum.

 

[ballinouttacntrol]

what kind of shark is it? The answer is still no but i'm curious. is it a bala?

 

[GhostShrimpMan]

Probably just a Great White.

 

[Yanbbrox]

Yes you are! Breakfast lunch and dinner all rolled into one

 

[jp80911]

if you had them for a year they should be around 6" at least. even serra would hit that size in the first year or so. what have you been feeding them? flakes?

 

[ballinouttacntrol]

if you had them for a year they should be around 6" at least. even serra would hit that size in the first year or so. what have you been feeding them? flakes?

 

[arrow]

No on the shark and what's your waterchange schedual, diet and filtration like on the reds tank?