am i just lucky?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

resimodos

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Jan 11, 2016
22
1
3
40
Maine
ive been keeping fish successfully for 20 years, mostly SA/CA cichlids. currently i have a 55 gal tank with 2 hang on the back type filters. it is heavily stocked so i do about a ten gallon water change daily. my fish thrive beautifully and i dont even own a water test kit. the only chemical i use is stress coat tap water conditioner. inside i have a 5" pleco, 4" jaguar cichlid, 7" oscar, 6" lima shovelnose catfish, and a 5" alligator gar. the gator gar was sold to me as a spotted gar by accident, so i may have to give him away once he gets big. I know i have future behemoths and am getting a 125 gal tank and a powerful canister filter in the near future and will split the fish between the 2 tanks. i like the dimensions on a 125 gal. so anyways i read all this stuff about water conditions and needing really large tanks and people will probably read this and think im nuts and violate a bunch of fishkeeping rules and guidelines but they are all seem active, happy, and get along peacefully. i live on the coast of southern Maine and maybe our tap water just happens to be good for fish from SA/CA. I do spend a lot of time tending to them with small daily water changes and the tank is clean and clear. So am i just lucky and get away with it or do people tend to exaggerate about everything?

my avatar pic shows my gar and shovelnose, but i will post a full tank shot later.
 
There's a thread about this. I haven't used conditioner in my tank in about 6 years. All is well. I used to then I forgot to add it once and never did again
 
hey man I'm not part of the stocking police lol but I think long term your gonna need more than just the 125 and the 55 to house those guys. Maybe 125 and a 75 at the least. The 55 isn't really good for any of the fish long term. Glad that its been working out for you. I love maine btw wife and i used to visit Bar harbor allot
 
  • Like
Reactions: resimodos
yeah your probably right, ill need to find a new home for a fish or 2 otherwise. thats what sucks about fishkeeping, some of these fish are just so interesting and intriguing, but get so large and not all of us are rich and can afford a 1000 gallon tank, and you are familiar with Maine so an outdoor pond would just be an ice cube damn quick and out of the question for tropical fish haha. i absolutely love my gator gar, never had a gar before but its just not realistic for me to keep him for life
 
hey man I'm not part of the stocking police lol but I think long term your gonna need more than just the 125 and the 55 to house those guys. Maybe 125 and a 75 at the least. The 55 isn't really good for any of the fish long term. Glad that its been working out for you. I love maine btw wife and i used to visit Bar harbor allot
The Stocking Police would be an awesome username... hmmm
 
Cold but beautiful in winter. Cadillac mountain was a favirote stop for us.
 
im familiar with there too jaws, i live in Old Orchard Beach, which believe it or not maine has a summer beach tourist resort. kinda like a cheap florida for canadians haha. too bad summer in Maine only lasts a couple months, but its a nice beach
 
im familiar with there too jaws, i live in Old Orchard Beach, which believe it or not maine has a summer beach tourist resort. kinda like a cheap florida for canadians haha. too bad summer in Maine only lasts a couple months, but its a nice beach
Months? Or a couple of days? LOL! Water is too cold for my liking.
 
  • Like
Reactions: resimodos
MonsterFishKeepers.com