Anacharis: Hardy or wimpy?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Lord Barium

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
May 30, 2007
210
0
0
Monday
Hi

I've heard wonderful things about ancharis, such as "it's a miracle plant!" "you could grow it in a bottle!" "toughest thing on the face of the eartH" and other exuberant exclamations about the ease at which one would care for it.

so of course, i had to get my hands on it. I planted it in my uuber planted tank (which has everything a planted tank could need), and watched it grow...brown. Within a week, almost all my anarchis looked like brown slime.:irked:

Skip back five or six years. I had bought anacharis for my first fishtank, and it did the same thing only slower. Every single time i bought it, it rotted then died.

So now, I had to throw away 10$ of slimy, dead anacharis. woohooo. Toughest plant every.

Out of curiosity I left one slimy gross brown thing in my tank, and miraculously, it started to grow again.

So know i am totally confused. It died in a tank that was practically built for it, but grew back from death.

Mabye i'm just so totally uncool in my planted tanks department that i kill off plants with stunning ease. But then again, i put plants that were much less hardy in the tank and they did fine. Something with my water parameters?

Anacharis: Hard miracle plant or wimpy wimp wimp? Or in between? Please share your thoughts.
 
im not sure about this specific plant but alot of plants were grown out of water and once fully under water die off then grow back after they are used to there new conditions. this always happens to my crypts they die off then come back after a while so im guessing they are the same way.

*not sure if you used it but excel will kill it off (i think i remeber hearing this)
 
I heard of hardy these guys were so i decided to try my hands with live plants. Well...they died within a few weeks. I was kind of skeptical about trying them again, but I did. Same thing happened once again. Whatever was left I threw outside in this ceramic water jug thing I have. It survived the winter. And then I finished my pond a few months ago and decided, why not? So I placed the 3 that I had left in a pot and now they grow like crazy now! I actually have a small sprig that I put in my tank to see if this one will grow.
 
A plant is a plant is a plant! The water (and temp.!) need to be optimum in order for any plant to thrive! Water is your water temperature? Hardness? PH? Anacharis IS one of the hardiest plants, but not if you put it in unfavorable conditions! What kind of lighting do you have? Wattage? Tank size? Depth? Were the other plants shading it? Anacharis will grow up to 3" a day! Yes, a day! If kept under optimum conditions! I've had tank fulls of it! Clue us in! What are the parameters of your tank?
 
i thought thats what all anacharis does when it first gets introduced into the tank.. my only experiece was trying it with goldfish thou.. and they chomped it before it had a chance
 
Hi everyone,
Anacharis has been growing in my pond for 2 years now and has been thriving. According to my experiences, anacharis (aka egeria densa) likes lower temperatures from 5 to 20 degrees. It also seems to like very hard water. Since my pond has a concrete waterfall, lime is continually leaking into the water making the water very hard and have a high pH. ANacharis also seems to thrive in medium low lights (2-4 hours) My pond is shaded by palms and a fence. I can't grow water lillies :(
I have tried it in my new south american tank setup (high temp. and low pH and very soft water) and it the seemed to melt, making a mess of mussy leaves in tank.

In my experiences a very easy plant to grow if given the right conditions.
 
I have had the same experience. Bought healthy anacharis and it gradually got lighter and lighter green and rotted away. The water of the tank it was in is soft and acidic, it has a lot of tetras in it. I am betting they dont like soft acid water. The lighting is very high, plenty of fertilizer and aquariumplants.com substrate, and pressurized CO2. Plants that are supposed to be more difficult to grow and get to thrive are really booming, but I tried anacharis twice, getting healthy plants from the store and after a week or two they were dead as a hammer.
 
rye;1960078; said:
I have had the same experience. Bought healthy anacharis and it gradually got lighter and lighter green and rotted away. The water of the tank it was in is soft and acidic, it has a lot of tetras in it. I am betting they dont like soft acid water. The lighting is very high, plenty of fertilizer and aquariumplants.com substrate, and pressurized CO2. Plants that are supposed to be more difficult to grow and get to thrive are really booming, but I tried anacharis twice, getting healthy plants from the store and after a week or two they were dead as a hammer.

My tank is basically the same (w/out co2) and my ancharis did the same thing except my tank has hard water.:eek:
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com