Anyone Feed Frogs to Their Fish?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Pomatomus

Piranha
MFK Member
Jul 7, 2009
1,691
162
81
Sarasota, FL
I've started feeding my oscar some small Cuban tree frogs (they're invasive here). She loves em!
 
Alright......pellets works good to.
 
they might release a toxin that can kill your oscar
 
i'm not hatin i think its a great idea
 
roflmao.. I knew I shoulda kept my original comment.. aka your gonna get crap for feeding live from some. But imo live food is apart of a healthy balanced diet. be that "live food" frozen,feeder fish, zucchini, worms, ect.. I'de be most concerned w/ bacterial fungal possabilities, and any live feeders caught can hold contaminents such as fertilizers, pesticides, ect..

and I do not recall the cubans haveing any type of toxin. the majority of toads do though. But they are rarely lethal or even harmful long term (the exception being a few of the poison dart species of frogs). and fish will spit them right back out unless starved generally. I'm not 100% so i would do some research on feeding the species before doing it. which is common sense imo.

EDIT: The problem with the link and what was stated.. is it lists a variety of predetors who are unaffected by the toxins, but that humans and pets should avoid them due to the irritation caused by the toxin. you'de be surprized how many creatures have "toxins" that do not effect other species, or are immune. Persoanlly though I wouldn't continue feeding them unless I found exactly what this toxin did, and it's impact upon fish. ie if a build-up of this toxin could occur in the pets body and kill it. or if it is harmless.

The Sticky about feeders is a fount of info as well. No i've never fed frogs, because it hasn't been practical but I've heard many Arrow keepers swear by them.

100% live is not neccisarily healthy, but neither is 100% pellets imo. Variety is key as our pets can't go search out what they nutritionally need.

My Oscar also loves crickets, minnows, pellets, frozen bloodworms, frozen mysis( def not his fav but will eat), and has decided to try the earthworms I feed my fire eels. And would keel over from stuffing himself with krill if i let him. frozen and/or freezedried. about 50-60% of his diet is pellets and the rest is something or other.
 
not sure how healthy it is, toxins aside, but i would imagine its got to be a semi-normal part of many fishes natural diets. frogs are abundant in many rivers and lakes, so i cant see fish like oscars passing on the chance for it.

that being said, i would worry about the frogs claws injuring the oscar.
 
i wouldnt feed something i find in my yard, unless i know its safe for the animal.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com