Apple Snails

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

CichlidL

Gambusia
MFK Member
Jul 10, 2011
175
0
16
Home
Hi
Can i put apple snails in my new tank ? i have heard that one should avoid keeping apple snails with fish?
 
Yeah, Apple snails and Plants definitely DO NOT go well together... i've had one demolish all the plants in my old tank once, and it was done within 12 hours...
 
Depending on the fish they may eat the snails.
 
I have a very large mystery snail in with my severums, jack dempsy, and salvini, and they all leave the snail alone. Occassionally a blood parrot will pick on it, but it can't do anything.
 
There have been stories about Cana Apple Snails killing long-bodied loaches. Haven't heard of them going after anything else though.

Cana's can eat fish. I've thrown in dead fish before and watched my Cana turn it into a skeleton very quickly. But when it comes to live healthy fish...well it'd have to catch the fish fish which is not likely with anything but slow moving, small, bottom-dwellers (probably why long-bodied loaches have been reported as targets).
As for whether the fish is a threat, well that depends on the fish really. But they are big tough snails so I'd figure anything that isn't big and aggressive or good at snail-killing would be fine.
 
an apple snail I had when I was younger would "stand" on the sides of the tank, and grab fish as they passed by. I woke up one morning to find it eating my ID shark, and the snail had munched on the tail half of it, and the poor thing was still alive.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com