P paddy62 Jack Dempsey MFK Member Oct 2, 2007 12 0 31 Brooklyn Oct 2, 2007 #1 Do red spotted newts stand a chance in a 55g tank with rock bass & perch?
N Nabbig2 Fire Eel MFK Member May 28, 2007 2,602 6 68 California Oct 3, 2007 #2 I would not risk it. The newt stands a chance of ending up as dinner for either of the fish. I suggest a smaller species of fish.
I would not risk it. The newt stands a chance of ending up as dinner for either of the fish. I suggest a smaller species of fish.
G guppy Small Squiggly Thing Apr 15, 2005 11,595 89 0 confused, lost, and lonely Oct 3, 2007 #3 Red spotted newts will do okay with nonaggressive community fish near their own size but are at risk with any type of bass.
Red spotted newts will do okay with nonaggressive community fish near their own size but are at risk with any type of bass.
L loconorc Feeder Fish MFK Member Sep 11, 2007 1,417 0 0 Virginny Oct 3, 2007 #4 Anything smaller than a guppy will get eaten, and anything bigger than a guppy will eat them.
C Connor0729 Fire Eel MFK Member Jan 21, 2007 1,391 1 68 Ontario, Canada Oct 3, 2007 #5 they wont stand a chance
L loconorc Feeder Fish MFK Member Sep 11, 2007 1,417 0 0 Virginny Oct 3, 2007 #6 Only question is how fast it will happen.
L loconorc Feeder Fish MFK Member Sep 11, 2007 1,417 0 0 Virginny Oct 3, 2007 #7 Not to mention you need a land area, which may or not be practical for you.
P paddy62 Jack Dempsey MFK Member Oct 2, 2007 12 0 31 Brooklyn Oct 3, 2007 #8 Saw the other post - yep I get it http://www.monsterfishkeepers.com/forums/showthread.php?t=94574 LOL - Thanks LOVESPUNAROUND.
Saw the other post - yep I get it http://www.monsterfishkeepers.com/forums/showthread.php?t=94574 LOL - Thanks LOVESPUNAROUND.
L loconorc Feeder Fish MFK Member Sep 11, 2007 1,417 0 0 Virginny Oct 3, 2007 #9 That thread was a joke in light of all the recent mixing species thread. Just a little poke at the newbies... But paddy, if you want to set up a newt enclosure without the fish, we'd be glad to help!
That thread was a joke in light of all the recent mixing species thread. Just a little poke at the newbies... But paddy, if you want to set up a newt enclosure without the fish, we'd be glad to help!