Are all these fish from the same place

[se1an]

These are the fish that i got in my 120
Dont worry if the shovelnose gets to big i have him a home when hes bigger.

Oscar
Silver Dollar
Tiger Shovelnose
Jaguar Cichlid
4 Line Pictus
Sailfin Pleco
Severum
Dempsey
Pike (venn)

 

[LBathory]

i know the jag isnt.

 

[se1an]

then where is the jag from?

 

[balton777]

Actually you have mixed South American and Central American fish which is pretty common with aquarists.

Oscar-S. America
Silver Dollar-S America
Tiger Shovelnose-S America
Jaguar Cichlid-Central America
4 Line Pictus-S America
Sailfin Pleco-S America
Severum-S America
Dempsey-Central America
Pike (venn)-S America

If you separate the Jag and Dempsey, it seems you would have an all S. American tank.

And with my limited knowledge about Tiger Shovelnose cats, they grow pretty quick. It won't be too long before he's able to eat your other fish.

 

[FSM]

when, not if the shovelnose gets too big for the 120. Those things get monstrous.

like the others said, they are from CA and SA.

 

[blacktip]

They'd all be from the same place if you picked them up from the same lfs...:rofl:

Seriously, though, a TSN would easily be able to turn on all of these fish once it got large enough. Mine is 15" and he still tries to eat my 6" silver dollars. They would be goners if they weren't so high bodied.

 

[Toby_H]

Oscar-S. America
Silver Dollar-S America
Tiger Shovelnose-S America
Jaguar Cichlid-Central America
4 Line Pictus-S America
Sailfin Pleco-S America
Severum-S America
Dempsey-Central America
Pike (venn)-S America

The above is true... But "South America" is a very big 'place'... there is a world of difference between Southern Argentina and Northern Venezeula... about 4,500 miles different. I believe your fish come from a 2~3,000 mile North/South range...

This doesn't mean you can't keep them together... but is simply food for thought.