Are bala sharks that hard to grow out?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Dégatdeau

Plecostomus
MFK Member
May 3, 2019
221
244
61
Québec City, Canada
I bought a small group of 5 bala sharks two months ago. All around 2". One died in quarantine the next day. I put them through two rounds of prazipro during their month in quarantine. One died after a couple weeks of quarantine. After a month in quarantine, I put them in a 90g with other small cyprinids. And now a third one turned pale and died. I am down to two. All the other fish in the tank are good, I have had them from 6 months to 5 years
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
I bought a small group of 5 bala sharks two months ago. All around 2". One died in quarantine the next day. I put them through two rounds of prazipro during their month in quarantine. One died after a couple weeks of quarantine. After a month in quarantine, I put them in a 90g with other small cyprinids. And now a third one turned pale and died. I am down to two. All the other fish in the tank are good, I have had them from 6 months to 5 years
esoxlucius esoxlucius
 
In my experience Bala sharks are one of the hardiest fish out there, but saying that, very young juveniles such as yours, as with any juvenile fish, can be susceptible to stress etc.

And another thing that I have learnt from bitter experience, and not many will agree, is that quarantining such juvenile fish can end in disaster. Tiny juvenile clown loach were always problematic for me. Then when I stopped quarantining them they started surviving, go figure, lol.

I realise now that my methods of quarantining were not ideal. I'd set a tank up especially for new arrivals, with seeded media etc. Good to go, right? Not necessarily. I believe quarantine tanks need to be just as mature as well aged set ups to give new additions, especially tiny juvies, the best shot.

My abject failure with clown loach taught me a lot.

I don't know what your quarantine procedures are, I'm just offering my perspective. My original group of Bala's were 2" when I got them. No quarantine, no problems whatsoever, the biggest is now about 11" and seven years old.

Or it could be something as innocuous as a "bad batch" with weak genes, who knows.
 
Esox hit the nail on the head regarding the basic premise of "quarantine". To me, quarantining a new arrival of absolutely any species is a must, no exceptions. If the fish in question is going into a single-species/single-fish aquarium, that tank is the quarantine tank...and the fish will be in quarantine indefinitely. Otherwise, a quarantine tank is a fully-mature, 100% cycled tank that is kept for that specific purpose. If I receive more than one fish from multiple sources at the same time...a rarity for me...then extra quarantine tanks can be set-up immediately using extra sponge filters that are kept constantly running in established aquariums. Either way...fish aren't just plopped into new "raw" aquariums under the guise of being quarantined.
 
Last edited:
MonsterFishKeepers.com