Are we underestimating fish intelligence?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Tanyoberu

Gambusia
MFK Member
Mar 10, 2006
247
1
16
NJ
We know some species of fish learn to recognize their owners/ feeders. My Uarus know when I'm going to feed them and when it's time to clean the tank! But I'm observing something new with one of my other fish, a columbian shark to be exact.

I had two in a brackish community tank. They'd chase each other in the tank, but they each had their own spots where they swam against the currents. So it was strange to see this particular shark on the opposite end of the tank. During feeding time I noticed he wasn't eating and then I also realized the other Shark was missing. Sure enough, there it was on the floor behind the tank! It was very dry, but I was able to flush water down his mouth and it was responsive so I put it back in the tank while I was preparing a 'lung machine' (I'll explain that later.) To my amazement, the stressed shark, seemed to be comforting the near-dead shark.

So I rigged a gravel cleaner to a pump and put the shark in the gravel cleaner so water would run through and around it. (My lung machine) Again, the stressed shark would swim next to the shark, and would swim in the exiting current, as if it could smell his friend. The shark eventually died and was discarded. And I did a major water change.

Today during observation, I watched the lonely shark sitting in a dead spot in the tank. Not swimming in a current, but just looking right at me. When I fed the rest of the fish, it moved out of the way since it was in the spot where most of the food collected. But it did not eat. Could this normal social fish be mourning? Are we underestimating fish intelligence?
 
.....

Schooling fish get stressed out when they're alone. I don't think it was mourning, I think it was stressed because it didn't have any fish of its species in the tank with it.
 
no i think people over estimate fish intelligence
 
I think it could have been mourning.

Whales (I know different than fish) will mourn. When someone in their colony is hurt/dead, they will use their noses and push the whale up to the surface for air. They will also do this with babies right after they are born.

I would think that fish are similar.

I had gotten a comet a while back.. like 2 years ago, and I noticed that he was lonely in a tank with no one else. He just sat there and didn't do anything. So I went out and bought a tank mate that even came out of the same batch at the store as him, and he perked right up. They played, and chased each other around, and now they are in a 1500 gallon tank with my koi.

When I take one out, I have to take the other out because they know when one is missing, and they get really stressed out no matter who else is in the tank with them.
 
I have read many accounts were fish will mourn the death of another. I know a few people who have had discus were two of them were mates one dies the other stopped eating and just sit around and eventually died.
 
fishaddict401;3891526; said:
Fish use instinct rather than brains.

That's like saying dogs use instinct rather than brains. When it's obvious through actions that they use both.
 
My jardini knows the concept of revenge
 
Anyone who's ever owned a cichlid can't deny some form of "brains" in fish.. some species are deffinately more intelligent then others. instincts impact behavior.. and behavior can be curbed by instinct. and I used cichlids in reference as many people have had experiance with these very personable, and personality exudeing fish. But there are many more.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com