Astyanax tetras-why are they not more popular on MFK?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

cichlidfish

Peacock Bass
MFK Member
Jun 18, 2005
4,643
978
120
54
It seems no one really keeps these larger tetra sp. They are very closely related to Brycons.
I wish I could get mexican tetras, but I love my astyanax bimculatus and can't wait for them to reach 6". Feeding time turns into a real frenzy which is awsome.

ImageUploadedByMonsterAquariaNetwork1333505398.486760.jpg


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app

ImageUploadedByMonsterAquariaNetwork1333504275.587637.jpg

ImageUploadedByMonsterAquariaNetwork1333504289.268803.jpg

ImageUploadedByMonsterAquariaNetwork1333504303.813553.jpg

ImageUploadedByMonsterAquariaNetwork1333505410.065835.jpg

ImageUploadedByMonsterAquariaNetwork1333505424.577510.jpg

ImageUploadedByMonsterAquariaNetwork1333505445.921533.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jexnell
I have 5 Astyanyx Jordani in a 29. They were originally the first fish in the tank after an overhaul because they were cheap and i didn't have a light yet, but they are some of the coolest fish i've kept. Really neat fish but tough to keep with tankmates. First I tried Barilius danios, which lasted about a week. I later found that at night the tetras would gang up on them and devour them alive when it got dark and they got stressed. After this i got some D. Compressiceps growouts a few months later, which worked out decently. they'd fight back so the Astyanyx quickly learned to keep their distance. I now have the tetras with a single exochochromis anagenys growout. the big issue with tankmates is feeding them. when alone they'd have little issue feeding, as they'd swarm the surface once the food hit then scrounge the bottom much like cories. But when i have them with other fish they always miss most of the food, making it difficult to ensure they get enough. they definetely lost weight until the comps were put in my 75. But they learned a good trick with the exo, who usually gets 99% of the food. The exo doesn't really swallow then move on. He just crams as much as he can into his mouth, then waits for it to begin disintingrate before crushing it. once there is nothing left in the water they just follow the exo. when he crushes the pellets about half ends up as suspended particles which the tetreas eat right up, coupled with hand feeding ensures they don't waste away.
 
I have 5 Astyanyx Jordani in a 29. They were originally the first fish in the tank after an overhaul because they were cheap and i didn't have a light yet, but they are some of the coolest fish i've kept. Really neat fish but tough to keep with tankmates. First I tried Barilius danios, which lasted about a week. I later found that at night the tetras would gang up on them and devour them alive when it got dark and they got stressed. After this i got some D. Compressiceps growouts a few months later, which worked out decently. they'd fight back so the Astyanyx quickly learned to keep their distance. I now have the tetras with a single exochochromis anagenys growout. the big issue with tankmates is feeding them. when alone they'd have little issue feeding, as they'd swarm the surface once the food hit then scrounge the bottom much like cories. But when i have them with other fish they always miss most of the food, making it difficult to ensure they get enough. they definetely lost weight until the comps were put in my 75. But they learned a good trick with the exo, who usually gets 99% of the food. The exo doesn't really swallow then move on. He just crams as much as he can into his mouth, then waits for it to begin disintingrate before crushing it. once there is nothing left in the water they just follow the exo. when he crushes the pellets about half ends up as suspended particles which the tetreas eat right up, coupled with hand feeding ensures they don't waste away.

Awsome story! How big did they get and do you have pics?
They sound a lot like my bimaculatus. They are pretty tough and go crazy at feeding time and are much quicker at getting food then the cichlids.
My a. Bimaculatus will pratically take food from your hand. Not shy at all.
They are great w/ aggressive cichlids and it is nice to have something different other then silver dollars or giant dianos.
You do have to watch them w/ cichlid fry or young cichlds. I lost some young HRPs to the tetras.
 
They are pretty small, about 2 inches and I doubt they'll get much bigger, little more then 3 inches as adults if they are lucky. really funny. they originally would ricochet off the walls and decor until about a week later now they rarely hit anything. they scrap well but as mentioned above the issue is that the lack of eyes makes them very slow to go after non live food so they need special attention with aggressive eaters
 
Weren't Jordani thought to be Mexicanis-the Mexican tetra?
Also buenos airies tetras look so much like astyanax tetras w/ the body shape and spot on the tail.


Sent from my iPhone using MonsterAquariaNetwork app
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com