BATF vs FATF id

[ATF]

So I have a chance to get some ATF, owner told me his two ATFs are both BATF. I just need a confirmation.

 

[Siddons11]

Pics?

Sent from my Samsung Galaxy Note II

 

[ATF]

View attachment 957801View attachment 957807View attachment 957806View attachment 957803 This is the first ATF

 

[ATF]

View attachment 957831View attachment 957832

 

[ATF]

View attachment 957835View attachment 957836View attachment 957837View attachment 957838View attachment 957839

 

[ATF]

Disregard Post #3, I mixed up the first and second ATF.

 

[Chicxulub]

Even I can't tell from the pics. BATF and FATF are the two hardest species to tell apart. You'd need a $3000 camera setup and a couple years of practice to get a picture good enough to really tell the difference in those species at that size. FWIW, they are a lot easier to tell apart in person than when looking at pics.

Read this thread and report back to us on what you feel that it is-

http://www.monsterfishkeepers.com/f...-amp-Forskahlii-same-tank-same-time-How-to-ID

 

[ATF]

I believed the ATF is a FATF, since there is black in the adipose fin BUT only half has black and the other half of the adipose is clear. BATF have completely dark/black adipose fin correct? Also the dorsal fin looks to be ahead of the pelvic fin. I tried looking for the big eyes, but I don't really know what considers as big eyes.

 

[Jiyowel]

Can u id this now? Hehe C Chicxulub

 

[Jiyowel]

I think its a batf