Beating a dead horse: tank size

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

nomadofthehills

Candiru
MFK Member
Nov 1, 2005
573
2
48
I just got home from work, where someone wanted to know how to help their sick oscar. They said they treated him with ick killer. He is supposedly about 4" long and they had him for a few months. They said he had stuff all on his body, so I asked if it was little white dots, they said no. I asked if was holes in the head area, tehy said no, it was like grey stuff growing on his body.

Then I asked tank size. They said 10g.






When people argue about tank size for an oscar and say minnimum is 75g, I get frustrated. They havn't worked in a petstore. Minnimum is not good, minnimum is:


Main Entry: min·i·mum
Pronunciation: 'mi-n&-m&m
Function: noun
Inflected Form(s): plural min·i·ma /-n&-m& /; or -i·mums
Etymology: Latin, neuter of minimus smallest; akin to Latin minor smaller -- more at MINOR
1 : the least quantity assignable, admissible, or possible


Any 12" fish would be HAPPY to live in a 55. Sure, a 75 isten times better. But even a 14" fish can live in a 55g, they can still turn around, trust me.

A 55g is better than a 10. It is better than a 20L. It is better than a 29, 30 hex, or 40 breeder.

These are where MOST potentially 12" fish wind up, so any fish is LUCKY to wind up in a 55.

Besides, if someone really likes their fish, they might upgrade to a bigger tank.


/rant

Anyway, I told that guy to raise the temp to 83, add lower the water level for extra 02, and do daily water changes with added salt until the oscar gets better. Is he gonna get a bigger tank? Probably not.
 
You work for a petstore you should have sold him some useless Anti- fungul medicine.

BAD EMPLOYEE :D

Just kidding I am Glad I don't have to deal with the public
 
I don't make commision, but I make more than anyone else in my department, even though I'm only 18. I'm also an Eagle Scout so even if I did i wouldn't sell useless crap :) Hey, i tell people to get cheaper stuff at homedepot all the time haha
 
I'm sorry but I'll never recommend a 55 gallon tank for a fish with the potential to grow 12"+ as a minimum. IMO a 15" wide or 18" wide tank is absolute minimum for those foot long fish. Just because the fish can barely turn around doesn't mean the tank is large enough. Now I do agree with you that a 55 is much, much better than a 10 gallon that's for sure.

My feeling is that people who take the time to come to a site like this to ask questions about their fish are the ones that want to take pretty good care of them, not just provide them the absolute minimum where their full grown fish will just barely be able to turn around. :)

just my $0.02 :thumbsup:
 
hehehehehe 10 gal? ROFL! that wouldn't even fit my heaters :/

(jager - 300w)

would this be okay for oscars dude? 55 gal and I have 2 :P when they get big enough they can swim with my other fishies in my 240 gal :P

DSCF3403.JPG
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com