Best color substrate/background for new tank

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

DaveB

Fire Eel
MFK Member
Feb 22, 2008
1,244
14
68
Miami
I'm going to be upgrading to a 150-180 soon from a 90 and am thinking that as long as I'm going through the effort I'd like to switch to sand. I'm wondering what the best option is for me though, in terms of bringing out the fish's colors. Right now I've got the generic cheap pea gravel from home depot in their tank.

I really like the look of a nice bright white-ish sand but I have white aragonite in my cichlid tank and sometimes I feel like it is too bright and washes out their colors. But I just put a black background on that tank as an experiment and I am finding that it dulls them so I wonder if my thinking that black would be better is incorrect.

My stock will be one silver aro, some datnoids (mostly IT, and an AT), a big distichodus lussoso, a juvenile distichodus sexfaciatus, a green terror (for now, till he gets his own tank), a ctenapoma, a big bala shark, and some pictus cats. I guess what I'm really looking for is opinions on what will bring out the colors on my distichodus, dats, and aro. Should I just go with the very light pool filter sand, or spend more on the black moon sand? Which will make the colors pop better? And should I use a background? The tank will be in the bedroom set a few feet out in front of the closet, so it'd be viewable from the back if I didn't use a background. But I'm willing to put the background on if it will help with their colors and appearance from the front. Would a black background make a huge difference?
 
Black substrate, Black background. An incredibly dark olive colour also works effectivelly as a background.

I'm using a fairly bright river sand with a black background because I like the contrast and natural look. Purely for 'enhancing' the colour and lighting, black substrate will make your Dats 'pop'!
 
i have 1 in black and 1 in smoke grey 3m color quartz aggregate. the black is outstanding in bringing out coloration. the grey( close to white) brightens up the tank but doesnt affect coloraton i.e. washout. great for digging cichlids, loaches etc. and easy cleaning too. good luck w/ your choice
 
I put the black background on the 90 and it looks incredibly good. So I'm going to pick up 6 feet of something black (hopefully I can find something at home depot that isn't 2 bucks a foot like the glossy stuff at pet stores) and see how that looks when I set up the new tank. Still not sure on the substrate though. The only black sand I know of is the stuff they sell at the LFS for 2 bucks a pound, which would cost too much. I'm also not sure where I'd find pool filter sand, plus isn't that too white? So I may just go with a bit of play sand or the existing pea gravel.

Is there a black sand that's cheap?
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com