Karen, you had the adjustable jack post up-side-down for wood structure - I guess you didn't read the instructions eh!

The bigger section is supposed to be up against the wood. Good illustrative pics there - a picture means a thousand words. I don't have any camera left at home with me or I'd snap some to share.
I've posted on other threads here about my situation for a 180g, which also was running parallel to the 16" spaced joists. BOTH side ends of of the tank were resting on bearing walls but the whole tank length-wise sat on only one single joist. Obviously not cool, so I added another 6' joist under the tank right before filling it up. My best friend, who is a steel building designer/engineer in another state, said it was fine the way it was (although he didn't see it in person). However, I was still being a little paranoid about the floor support so last Sunday I added one more 5' joist on the other side using the adjustable floor jack to support one end (instead of using the 2x4 wall as I already did for the other new joist on the other side), while the other end is resting on a masonry 8" thick bearing internal wall. So now my tank is resting on an area of a total of 72"x32" with support of 5 joists that are 8" evenly spaced with one outer most joists being quadruple 2x10's support under second floor's stairs. I can sleep soundly at night now.
OP, I hope you could use these posts as references. A couple of notes:
- Add joists when the tank is empty to allow the new joists to be snuggly fit when added to take on some loads.
- Use adjustable floor jacks (mono post would be even better but bigger in size and more expensive) to help with this work.
Good luck.
edit: After all it's your house so only you could make the ultimate decision on adding more support or not. That's how I looked at it. Only use the info as reference/guide to help make your wise decision. I thought doing what I did was not possible due to very tight space available to do the work (big furnace and its ducts are right under the tank!), but I managed it!