black tip shark or 4 line pimedela

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

arowana man

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Oct 17, 2007
1,324
6
0
36
Pittsburgh, PA
which one sould i get. who gets bigger.
 
I'm assuming you mean the Columbian Cat shark or Black Finned Shark (hopefully not a real Black Tip!!!:nilly::D). They get about 12" and eventually need to go in Brackish water (we often adjust them to full saltwater at work). Here's a link...http://www.planetcatfish.com/catelog/species.php?species_id=700

We have 2 big 4-lines at work in our 720 gallon and they can definitely handle themselves with large and aggressive fish. The choice is yours....http://www.planetcatfish.com/catelog/species.php?species_id=653
 
petsmart calls them black tip. lol. im leaning towards the pim
 
i say you should get the black tip shark:D:D:D JK
 
maybe ill get both.lol
 
my petsmart (my work) calls them silver-tipped sharks. i would get the pims unless you want brackish
 
i had a columbian and didn't like it at all. i was, however, the hardiest of the brackish fish i tried for some reason. i have been thinking about getting a 4-lined, but i think the pictus are a little better looking
 
pwmin;1340403; said:
i had a columbian and didn't like it at all. i was, however, the hardiest of the brackish fish i tried for some reason. i have been thinking about getting a 4-lined, but i think the pictus are a little better looking
pictus dont get as big as the four line. i didnt know silver tips were brackish. so ill go with the 4 line pim
 
arowana man;1341254; said:
pictus dont get as big as the four line. i didnt know silver tips were brackish. so ill go with the 4 line pim
yeah, thats my prob w/ getting a pictus. ill prob just hold out for a perruno or wait a little to find a nice lima
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com