Never followed up on this because the next day, the gray was gone. He looks good and poops wood. I gave him filamentous green hair algae in big clumps, but they are still there. I guess I'll wait and see what he likes to eat. I had to do a 90% water change because his water smelled nasty after the second day. So I added more filtration and even more live culture from other filters. Oddly, he did not eat the live worms I gave him. He's probably still getting used to things, or recovering from the rotten water episode.