Breeding feeder fish

PredatorPiqued

Plecostomus
MFK Member
Mar 22, 2020
112
105
51
29
Maine
I'm about to get a 55 gallon tank set up. Is it possible to breed Molly's, convicts, or another feeder fish, and also raise them in the same tank??? If so witch ones would be the best choice. I've never done this before
 

tlindsey

Silver Tier VIP
MFK Member
Aug 6, 2011
23,258
24,119
1,660
Ohio
I'm about to get a 55 gallon tank set up. Is it possible to breed Molly's, convicts, or another feeder fish, and also raise them in the same tank??? If so witch ones would be the best choice. I've never done this before
[/QUOTE
You can breed them and raise them in the same aquarium but after a couple generations from the same group there will be weaker genes and deformed fish.
 

PredatorPiqued

Plecostomus
MFK Member
Mar 22, 2020
112
105
51
29
Maine
So if I was to put a divider up and separate young from parent, are you saying that after awhile the original parents will produce deformed fish? Initially having to buy more adults every so often for breeding?
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey

tlindsey

Silver Tier VIP
MFK Member
Aug 6, 2011
23,258
24,119
1,660
Ohio
So if I was to put a divider up and separate young from parent, are you saying that after awhile the original parents will produce deformed fish? Initially having to buy more adults every so often for breeding?
No if the fry grow up and start to breed with the parents or each other the same strain will become weaker and start to produce fish that will easily become sick and some will become deformed. I suggest switching up with a different male or female from different stock after a few times of the same pair.
 

Hybridfish7

Bronze Tier VIP
MFK Member
Dec 4, 2017
2,561
2,425
739
in a 55 you're not gonna be able to either find, let alone catch fry if you intend to use them as feeders. unless you mean just cover it in plants and wait a year for everything's population to be unnecessarily high.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey

duanes

MFK Moderators
Staff member
Moderator
MFK Member
Jun 7, 2007
20,938
26,161
2,910
Isla Taboga Panama via Milwaukee
Although I didn't breed swordtails to be feeders, I liked to have a constant resupply for dither fish.
Leaving females to drop fry in the main tank usually meant the fry would last about a minute.
What I would do is watch for pregnant females, move them to a sump, or separate tank to deliver, soon after, pop the females back back in the main tank.
Pregnant female.

fry growing out in a planted sump
 

PredatorPiqued

Plecostomus
MFK Member
Mar 22, 2020
112
105
51
29
Maine
Do you think it would be do able then to have a divider in a 55 and move the parents after they produce fry to the other side? If not ideally what would the set up look like?
Has anybody else tried breeding feeders to supply their own fish and how was it set up?
 

AaronKWolfe

Piranha
MFK Member
Oct 24, 2019
324
277
77
48
Do you think it would be do able then to have a divider in a 55 and move the parents after they produce fry to the other side? If not ideally what would the set up look like?
Has anybody else tried breeding feeders to supply their own fish and how was it set up?
I've bred guppies as feeders for some of my smaller cichlids, but they didnt breed enough for it to be a readily available food source. I just had a 30 gallon bin with a bunch of Java moss and plants in it and a sponge filter. A payara is a much larger fish that will eat more than what I had (for me it was a small pike cichlid, compressiceps in a 29 while in college), you'd probably be better off just buying/catching fish and just quaranting them for a month or so. Or just convert your payara to frozen food and not have to worry about this.
 

tcomollo

Feeder Fish
Jun 1, 2019
3
10
3
43
Would a payara eat red wiggler earth worms? Im not super familiar with that type of fish, so i dont know. I grow red wigglers in storage containers full of shredded cardboard and old food and stuff for the worms to compost. I feed the worms to my new world cichlids, bichirs, catfish, ghostknife, and even the black skirt tetras eat them. Most of the comet goldfish I have now do not like them, but I have seen other comets eat the worms.

On a separate note, I have had five or six convicts turn into hundreds in a 55 gallon aquarium. They take care of there fry so I did not have to separate any out. Thet just had fry and chased off the previous batch when thet were somewhat grown. I have been told and noticed that convicts are not ideal feeder fish, however. I was told by someone at a fish store that they have sharp fins? I dont know. Maybe someone else wants to weigh in on that.
 
zoomed.com
hikariusa.com
aqaimports.com
Store