Budget black sand?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

903Herp

Jack Dempsey
MFK Member
Nov 23, 2014
261
38
31
North east texas
So in the 240 I want to do black sand without breaking the bank. I heard the black diamond sand blasting sand is a no go. Anyone know of a place to buy fish safe black sand at a good price.
 
Tahitian moon sand is a little fine for my taste, but it is beautiful. Tractor Supply Warehouse sells black sand...I believe it to be #12 in coarseness...
The sand is sold as sandblasting sand and it will need to be thoroughly cleaned before putting it in the tank...but compared to moon sand, waaay cheaper.
 
Shot blasting sand is often crushed slag from metal smelters, and can be incredibly sharp, may not good for loaches, or other bottom dwelling fish
 
So in the 240 I want to do black sand without breaking the bank. I heard the black diamond sand blasting sand is a no go. Anyone know of a place to buy fish safe black sand at a good price.
Curious why or where you've heard black diamond is no good? I've had it in many tanks with zero ill effects. Doesn't effect barbels of my bottom feeders, grows plants fine, looks great and does not effect water quality. At less than $10 for 50#s it cannot be beaten.
 
  • Like
Reactions: millerkid519
I'm pretty sure I bought my black sand for like a steal at petsmart like 7-8 years ago. They had a sale and bought a lot. I'm thinking of going to natural sand now to bring out the colors of my fish.
 
Shot blasting sand is often crushed slag from metal smelters, and can be incredibly sharp, may not good for loaches, or other bottom dwelling fish
I believe it's coal slag not metal. If that's good or bad Idk I'm assuming much fear is based off comparisons to carbon, which can become a nitrate leecher. I don't think it's any sharper than Tahitian moon black sand.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com