But What Do The Fish Prefer? - Interesting Study on Tank Background Color

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

HumuhumuFan

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
May 1, 2021
17
12
8
48
TLDR: Study of Oscar fish showed improved growth rates and lower stress markers in fish raised with a red background. Blue fared the worst.


Methods:
120 Oscar fish with an average weight of 9.14 ± 0.34 g that were approximately the same size in terms of weight and length were randomly distributed into 12 aquariums (60 × 50 × 35 cm) and divided into four treatments (aquariums with blue, white, yellow, and red background colors) and each treatment in three replicates (10 fish per aquarium). The aquariums walls were covered with blue, white, yellow, or red sheeting, and all these aquariums were placed in the same light intensity.
Results
Fish cultured in the red aquariums had significantly higher final weight and WG compared to those cultured under the other tank colors.
Plasma cortisol, glucose, and lactate values of Oscar fish were significantly higher in the blue aquariums compared to other tank colors.

Conclusions
The Oscar fish cultured in the red aquariums had higher final weight and WG, lower FCR, and higher immune competence when compared to those cultured in aquariums of other colors. Also, GH and IGF-1 relative gene expression levels were meaningfully higher in fish cultured in yellow and red aquariums. The fish cultured in the blue aquariums had the highest stress levels as exhibited by high values of plasma cortisol, glucose, and lactate compared to other tank colors. These findings reveal that the most suitable tank color for the efficient production of juvenile A. ocellatus is red, while blue tank color is unsuitable. It is suggested that this research be performed in different life stages of the Oscar fish. Also, the effects of other colors on the performance of this species can be evaluated.

I have truthfully never considered this topic before but stumbled upon this study when Googling what type of background to use on my future Oscar tank. Not crazy about the results, as I think red would look pretty weird, but it never occurred to me to consider that fish see things differently. It's discussed in the article, the results are not the same for all species based on other experiments - sturgeon seem to prefer black backgrounds, goldfish like white.
 
Why no clear tanks or black? This study feels incomplete.

I paint my sides and back with matte black and the fish seem a lot happier knowing the limits of their enviroment.

Blue seems like it would make everything look like the sky?

Okay I see they discussed black. I'm going to have to do a deeper read on this later.

Super neat! Thanks for sharing!
 
Very interesting
My thought would be it depends on the environment the fish are naturally from to a degree. Red would somewhat mimic the murky waters of the Amazon. Something like a mbuna or even reef fish have bluer water and theoretically prefer a blue background.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HumuhumuFan
If we're really going to talk about what color background the fish would pick out, i have terrible believing there's 1 right answer even among a single species. That's like saying people prefer the walls on their houses all painted green or blue etc. Everybody has their preferences and I'm sure there's colors that are more calming or more alarming in general but like most other things we've found out in fish keeping, i think there's variation among individual fish.
 
If we're really going to talk about what color background the fish would pick out, i have terrible believing there's 1 right answer even among a single species. That's like saying people prefer the walls on their houses all painted green or blue etc. Everybody has their preferences and I'm sure there's colors that are more calming or more alarming in general but like most other things we've found out in fish keeping, i think there's variation among individual fish.
Perhaps…but they tested a 120 Oscars in this study there was a clear difference in growth and health between those in red or blue tanks. Maybe red does better mimic the tannin rich Amazonian waters like Deadeye mentioned, resulting in less stress for this species?
 
  • Like
Reactions: HumuhumuFan
Glad people found it as interesting as I did. As Desert Bus said, I'd like to have seen no background (aka clear) included as well. I'd also like to see an experiment were maybe you had a tank that was red on one end, and green on the other for example and see if the fish spent significantly more time on one versus the other. It really opens up a lot of interesting possibilities.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com