CA cichlid ID help

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

PhishMon84

Potamotrygon
MFK Member
Feb 13, 2017
1,418
1,464
164
I don’t know
Can anyone help ID this fish- it was sold as a asthaheros rostratum (maybe) the owner of the store could recall which astaheroes it was. It's about 5" with a black throats and pink and yellow above
---
TMA: Sat May 27 2017 08:49:21 GMT-0400 (EDT).jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: cichlidfish
There are a number of rostrum color morphs, some more yellow, some dark.
Here are some of mine to compare.
IMG_8957_zpssimex1vy.jpg

IMG_8479_zpszvtqhlsr.jpg

I have also kept a few other species there is also
Astatheros robertsoni
IMG_8831_zps6ddbnrcr.jpg

Astatheros longimanus, and a few more I have not been ducky enough to get yet
IMG_9858_zpsrwp1kxyf.jpg
 
Thanks Duanes I actually was reading a thread of yours wth these same photos, which sparked my post. I figured you'd be the guy.
Honored to get a reply from such a high profile member!
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
I adjusted your photo to make it easier to see for me, and it does look like rostrum to me, and a fine specimen. There are other Astatheroine (actually the genus is now, Cribroheros) like alfari, and altifrons you may want to google, to compare though, but I believe rostrum is correct.
fullsizeoutput_451.jpeg
 
I agree w/ Duane, definitely cribroheros rostrum. They are no longer astherheros due to recent reclassification. As they get older, the colors get really nice. It takes a very long time for them to grow. This one I have is over 8". I bought he/she in 2009.
Very nice fish OP.

IMG_3611.JPG

IMG_3612.JPG

IMG_3613.JPG

IMG_3615.JPG

IMG_3616.JPG

IMG_3618.JPG

IMG_3619.JPG

IMG_3657.JPG

IMG_3661.JPG
 
Soooo $10.00 well spent?
Seeing this things coloration I had to grab it- I also got a Robertsoni there a few months ago and it's about 5" and tall
 
  • Like
Reactions: cichlidfish
Soooo $10.00 well spent?
Seeing this things coloration I had to grab it- I also got a Robertsoni there a few months ago and it's about 5" and tall

Definitely a good price. You'll love both species. Some cichlids lose color as they get older, but not these cribroheros. They are well worth the wait. I keep c. Robertsoni and c. Rostrum together with no aggression issues at all. In fact they ignore each other. They are usually too busy shifting through the sand as they are CA eartheater equivalent to geos.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com