Can fish-keeping be considered a disorder?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

shekes

Jessica Rabbit
MFK Member
Aug 14, 2005
626
1
0
45
Toon Town
What do you think?

I am no psycholgist, but I think sometimes keeping fish really is a form of OCD (obsessive compulsive disorder), and, in some case could be detrimental to the quality of life.
Keeping one tank with nice colourful fish like discus, Africans or saltwater is relaxing and good for mental health. But is an obsession with huge aggressive, jumping, crawling, flying, venomos and even electric monsters; life-feeding, gruesome videos, fanatic dedication to WCs, building ponds, fish rooms and even huge buildings dedicated to fish always normal/positive/healthy?

I am sure somebody here can tell us a sad story how his RTC ate his newborn baby, his wife was electrocuted when helping with WCs or his mother had a heart attack whe she met his MBU Puffer face to face in the dark.

Take me:
A year ago I got my first tank to decorate my living room. Six months later I had 13 tanks with over 40 species of fish and amphibians, was spending my mornings chopping beefheart, my afternoons looking for fish online or posting on this forum, and in the evenings I would stare into my tanks.

I had an Irish gf who was a big help with WCs. When she was here, I used to pay less attention to her than to my Crenicichlas. She said "You have too many fish tanks!" and eventually went home to dear old Dublin. (I hope Ash will take her place soon. ;) )

I just got of the phone with her.
Guess what?
Yes! She is setting up a tank in dear old Dublin!
She contracted the desease! She needs her regular WCs now. I feel bad.

And then there is peanut who dreams about Chrenicichlas, Oddball who thinks his grandpa was a pleco, Guppy who met, studied and ate every single species of fish on this planet, and this Canadian guy who build a 50.000 gallon tank around his house.

Shopping can be a disorder. Gambling is a serious desease. Don't tell me fish-keeping is always healthy!
 
only if you hord them and keep them in terrible condition's , like some ppl do with dog's and cat and so on... :grinyes:

If you have multiple tank and all are in excellent conditon's for your fish then HELL NO BOY !you just in love with the fishy's :D


:thumbsup:



?? how those discus fry???
 
I don't think it's a human disorder, just a buffer for agriphobia and bad TV programming
 
OCD huh? well, it might be. I personally think It takes a special person to raise and love fish. You know, an animal lover. Would you want a lazy person caring for your fish? I have had a few all niters to correct fish troubles.
Hey, isn't ocd related to inteligence. I've never herd of a dumb person with OCD.
If it will make me look smarter I say OCD.
 
funny thread you started Shekes maybe you can add spousal problems as well because the fact i do suffer from ocd in regards to aquatic and reptiles and and and oh you get the picture anyways i'm lucky enough to still be attached despite my obsession :D
 
Fish keeping a mental disorder? Nah, I definitely do not have a disorder. If anyone does it's the fish! They say the darndest things. They probably have ADD Because they just talk and talk and talk and sometimes it's all gibberish like "Hey, your bathrobe doesn't match the carpet anymore!" I yell and scream at them to shut up and five minutes later there they are again jabbering away like monkeys at a pest control convention.
And singing?!? Gawd, they sing at the tops of their lungs all night long sometimes even when they don't know all the words! "O-oh say can you see? By the Vee Cee R's light!" I mean, how can a normal person sleep with all that going on.
Oh, and they stare... Always watching what I do so they can tell my wife later.
 
turtall said:
Fish keeping a mental disorder? Nah, I definitely do not have a disorder. If anyone does it's the fish! They say the darndest things. They probably have ADD Because they just talk and talk and talk and sometimes it's all gibberish like "Hey, your bathrobe doesn't match the carpet anymore!" I yell and scream at them to shut up and five minutes later there they are again jabbering away like monkeys at a pest control convention.
And singing?!? Gawd, they sing at the tops of their lungs all night long sometimes even when they don't know all the words! "O-oh say can you see? By the Vee Cee R's light!" I mean, how can a normal person sleep with all that going on.
Oh, and they stare... Always watching what I do so they can tell my wife later.

lmfao :ROFL:
 
hahaah. you know it shekes. it is a disorder with LOTS of people. i spend more money on fish than any other hobby or recreation. i was just at my long time family friends house who i introduced to fishkeeping...............she now has 4 tanks in her house and 2 at work. this all started from 1 tank with 2 freakin convicts. she now has about 400 convicts of all different sizes in a 70 gallon tank. they are all her little babies. hahahah. then she has an african tank and a plant tank with tetras, a lone common pleco in a 60 gallon who is like 2 feet long and a tank of mixed central americans with guess what.....a few more of her baby convicts as well. i just introduced her to the python today and now im sure shes gonna get more tanks because her water changes just got a whole lot easier. id say it is a disease. addiction in all forms is a disease and im an addict as well!!!!!!!!
 
Theres a cycle involved in it though. You start with few tanks, you go crazy and get several more, you get overloaded and decide to downgrade and youre back to step one. And repeat... Thats the way it has been for me at least. :D
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com