can gymnogeophagus go in a community tank?

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

cichlid_starter

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
May 31, 2009
813
0
0
Indianapolis
I have been doing some researching on them and have found very mixed answers. I have a 75 gal community tank with gouramis and tetras. Will any species of gymnogeophagus be able to go in that tank as far as compatibility? I would like to do a pair but if it means a more peaceful fish I will just do one.
 
cichlid_starter;3519173; said:
I have been doing some researching on them and have found very mixed answers. I have a 75 gal community tank with gouramis and tetras. Will any species of gymnogeophagus be able to go in that tank as far as compatibility? I would like to do a pair but if it means a more peaceful fish I will just do one.


The one main difference in the fish is that it lives in normally cool water...unlike most tropical fish that require temperatures in the higher temps. I can't speak to their temperament...but keep in mind that they are still cichlids...and as such unpredictable at times.
 
They are fairly peaceful, I have 8 in my 75 and there is only mild aggression between them.
 
Thanks for the advice guys.

Has anyone actually had them in a community tank? I have read a couple articles on them where the writer put them in his community tank but he didn't say anything about how it went or what else he had in the tank because it wasn't the focus of the article.
 
I had one of the females in a 29 gallon community for a week or two, it did fine other than chewing the tail off the angelfish.
 
I have kept them with livebearers without a problem, although Mo's advice should be taken seriously. In warm water they can become aggressive, but after a time they then seem to become increasingly suseptable to fungus and disease.
IMG_0087.jpg

IMG_03772.jpg
 
I'd go with a group of mouthbrooders (gymnogenys-type) vs. a pair of substrate spawners (rhabdotus-type). I've found that pairs of rhabdotus-type can be pretty disruptive in a community setting. Not violent like convicts or the like but pretty close.

I've had good luck keep Gymnos with flexible-temp tetras like Buenos Aires, Bloodfins, black tetras, etc. Also, I think that some Gourami's (blue, opaline, etc.) are able to do well in cooler water. No experience here though.

My advice is to give it a try...

Matt
 
dogofwar;3519619; said:
I'd go with a group of mouthbrooders (gymnogenys-type) vs. a pair of substrate spawners (rhabdotus-type). I've found that pairs of rhabdotus-type can be pretty disruptive in a community setting. Not violent like convicts or the like but pretty close.

I've had good luck keep Gymnos with flexible-temp tetras like Buenos Aires, Bloodfins, black tetras, etc. Also, I think that some Gourami's (blue, opaline, etc.) are able to do well in cooler water. No experience here though.

My advice is to give it a try...

Matt

They are supposed to do fine in a cooler temp but I haven't dropped the temp on them before.

What's the highest temp I should have on the Gymnos?
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com