Candling question

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

br13tr

Feeder Fish
MFK Member
Aug 26, 2010
13
0
0
New Freedom PA
Hello, this is my first post and I will confess to no small amount of nervousness as I have seen a significant amount of people saying 'learn to read', 'read the forums' and so forth. Firstly, just to get past that - I have read everything I can find, I have also done a lot of research outside of this including as many reference and source works as I can get hold of - but I really want some 'live' feedback so to speak.
I picked up a coral cat egg last week from my LFS, I ensured they didn't remove it from the water to prevent air, rechecked my system to ensure nothign strange in water quality - basically did my due diligence. I then sat back to wait, having assumed they had candled the egg to ensure it was viable. After 6 days I decided that I should check it myself and I cannot see either an egg sac or anything resembling a shark inside. I assume this is a 'wind egg' and the LFS are fine about returning it (although the want a water sample too which I find confusing as a wind egg doesn't have anything to do with my water quality but still.)
My concern is that somehow the shark is there, and I'm not seeing it - or that it's just "too early in the process". I don't want to risk carrying it back to the shop to find that I missed something obvious or risk damaging a viable shark. Wanted to get some thoughts on this from the experts here.

Thanks!
 
Yes, that does look empty to me too. At least if you can't make anything out, there should be some dark "forms" in there. I would return it.
 
Thank you for the help and the kind assistance. My LFS has been very helpful and they will re-credit the money tonight to me, they have made the whole things very painless and easy which is very typical of my experiences with them. For anyone within Range - 'That Fish Place' in Lancaster area, PA is an awesome retailer. :)
 
br13tr;4419337; said:
Thank you for the help and the kind assistance. My LFS has been very helpful and they will re-credit the money tonight to me, they have made the whole things very painless and easy which is very typical of my experiences with them. For anyone within Range - 'That Fish Place' in Lancaster area, PA is an awesome retailer. :)

Good thing man. I might be in your best interest to buy a baby shark. Some people struggle with getting them to eat, even though i had no problems with mine. Squid is the magic food nothing can resist.
 
Thanks for the comments, agreed I would be have been pissed too but with the way some stores are nowadays i'm never certain. I'm going to keep looking for a recently born coral cat, but no luck yet looking around. I'll keep on it!
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com