canister filter question

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

the big kahuna

Aimara
MFK Member
Oct 13, 2007
783
676
130
new york city
can anyone explain the difference of using a canister for mechanical and biological...which is better for a moderatlely stocked 240 tank and whats the best way to load a canister filter do i need carbon? is the blue/white filter pads needed and do i need scrubbies or ceramic rings
 
Which canister filters were you looking at purchasing? Different brands/models provide better filter types, least that is what I have learned.

For example, on my 100 gallon I run a XP3 for bio/chem and a Magnum 350 for mech. Both are canister filters.

I do not know if this is overkill, but the tank is sure as heck clean.
lol
 
Canisters are great for both mechanical and biological filtration. You can pretty much put what you want in there, but the general idea is to have your coarse mechanical media on the bottom (i.e. where the water enters), then the biological media (ceramic rings, etc.) above that, then your finer mechanical media on top for finer polishing of the water before it's returned to the tank. You generally don't need carbon after the tank has been established for a while unless you are removing medications, etc. On a 240 gallon tank, you may consider a sump setup over canisters. I would want at least three larger canisters on a tank that size, but you could get the same results by switching to a sump for roughly the same money or less.

Big country, I think the two canisters you have on your 100 is fine and a nice setup for that size tank. I'm a big fan of the XP3 and the 350 and it's not over-filtered by any means.
 
if your are looking for bio filtration... go with ehiem pro series. but david has the right idea going.. with the tank size you have, a sump would be the best way to go for you:D
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com