I emailed NJ fish and game. They said it is most likely a white perch due to mouth size. First one I know of from any of my friends that we caught out of this pond.
Sent from my HTCONE using MonsterAquariaNetwork App
I cant really tell by the picture, but is it a whitefish of some kind? normally you can tell it has an adipose fin behind the dorsal fin, but that fin is just a blur on my screen. it looks like its too pointed to be an adipose.