change substrate..

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

jlieskovan

Candiru
MFK Member
Mar 11, 2012
261
2
48
San Francisco
after having a tank established with fish in it, what is the best way to change the substrate? will it mess up my good bacteria?

the reason i want to change is to get a darker one, I'm trying to get the colors of my fish to be better...

setup is

eheim ecco pro x2

1 peacock bass
1 ornate bichir

thanks guys
 
BB are all over the tank, but most will not be in the substrate. Regardless, the BB will repopulate over time, so any large changes in the decor (like substrate) can be addressed by simply lowering feeding amounts and then increasing food amounts gradually over a period of time (like a week.)

There is not one best way to do this. Some recommend removing fish, then doing the change, especially if the change can be done quickly. Others will do it more slowly and carefully while the fish are still in the tank, using a scooper. If the tank can be divided with a temporary wall (like egg crate), the second method seems pretty good. Since some fish are biters, jumpers or skittish, while others aren't, it's hard to say which way is better.

If you have large rocks/driftwood and the substrate hasn't been worked for quite a while, there will be a risk of toxic gases when move these. That might be a reason to remove the fish. Most people don't have this issue, but deep substrates that have not been moved or have been covered for a long time have a real risk.

Moving the substrate will cloud the water, and if it's sand, send dangerous particles to the filter, so it's best to turn off the filter during the process or cover the intake with a sponge. You can turn the filter on periodically to keep the water from going stale if the change takes a while. For sand, I'd certainly leave the sponge in place with the filter on until the substrates has settled.
 
BB are all over the tank, but most will not be in the substrate. Regardless, the BB will repopulate over time, so any large changes in the decor (like substrate) can be addressed by simply lowering feeding amounts and then increasing food amounts gradually over a period of time (like a week.)

There is not one best way to do this. Some recommend removing fish, then doing the change, especially if the change can be done quickly. Others will do it more slowly and carefully while the fish are still in the tank, using a scooper. If the tank can be divided with a temporary wall (like egg crate), the second method seems pretty good. Since some fish are biters, jumpers or skittish, while others aren't, it's hard to say which way is better.

If you have large rocks/driftwood and the substrate hasn't been worked for quite a while, there will be a risk of toxic gases when move these. That might be a reason to remove the fish. Most people don't have this issue, but deep substrates that have not been moved or have been covered for a long time have a real risk.

Moving the substrate will cloud the water, and if it's sand, send dangerous particles to the filter, so it's best to turn off the filter during the process or cover the intake with a sponge. You can turn the filter on periodically to keep the water from going stale if the change takes a while. For sand, I'd certainly leave the sponge in place with the filter on until the substrates has settled.

that pretty much covers it...+1
 
ok cool guys.. yeah the tank is not too big, its 55g, and i move the decor quite often and vacuum the gravel once a weeks so i should be ok.. and I'm just going to replace it with a darker gravel no sand.
 
you should be fine... just be careful moving stuff around w/ a tankful of fish..:)
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com