Changing direction, 210g stocking

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

SpeedRacer

Jack Dempsey
MFK Member
Apr 11, 2010
35
11
38
Central NJ
So after running quite a few tanks in my fish room over the last 15 years, I’m going down to a single tank or maybe 2. One is a 7’ 210g. I’ve kept quite a variety of fish in that time, mostly African species, but a good handful of the more hearty SA/CA types as well as several L number plecos. I’ve been wracking my brain over stocking the 210, as I would like it to be a nice display tank. I thought about Africans again but don’t want the dull silver females that come along with buying juvenile groups. So I’m thinking of some SA species. I’ve kept Geo Tapajos in the past and I think I’d like to build around a nice group of 6-8 them. But I’m struggling to consider tankmates. The tank has a homemade rock background, pool filter sand, and will have plenty of driftwood(not shown in pic) and rock structure with some open areas. FX5 and 6 will filter it there so plenty in that regard. FWIW, in other tanks, I also have a small group of Cory Weitzmani, 2 WC L141, 3 L075, and 5 smaller L404. I’d thought about moving all of them into the 210 as well but I’m not sure how the competition for food will go in that scenario. What other colorful/active tankmates would you suggest? I have well water, but not terribly hard at 7.7-7.8 pH, GH of about 9.5 and KH of about 4.5. When I checked it in the past, tap comes out at about 210 TDS.

IMG_8791.jpeg
 
I love the Red Head Tapajos! Great tankmates would be any of the acara's or port cichlids, severums (no go with plants) chocolate cichlid, true parrot cichid, Urau, Oscar,etc.

My Geo Red Heads grew quite slowly, but I have heard they grow much quicker with very frequent water changes.....internet hearsay.

Ive got a plan for the next tank to be big and full of Geos....

Keep us posted!
 
  • Like
Reactions: SpeedRacer
With your pH, and hardness, you may want to choose the species you keep carefully.
Many of the east of the Andes, Amazonian Geophagines would prefer pH 7.0 and below, and minimal hardness.
IMG_3279.jpegIMG_5418.jpegIMG_3417.jpeg
There are Geophagines from west of the Andes, the red hump group (G steindachneri, and pellegrini) that would be a better fit, for your water parameters.
Or there are the shoaling, Central American earth eating equivalents too Geophagus of Thorichthys, and Cribrheros, that would also be a better match up for your water.
Below Cribroheros rostratus
1707230767614.png1707230808813.png
 
  • Like
Reactions: SpeedRacer
With your pH, and hardness, you may want to choose the species you keep carefully.
Many of the east of the Andes, Amazonian Geophagines would prefer pH 7.0 and below, and minimal hardness.
View attachment 1535075View attachment 1535076View attachment 1535077
There are Geophagines from west of the Andes, the red hump group (G steindachneri, and pellegrini) that would be a better fit, for your water parameters.
Or there are the shoaling, Central American earth eating equivalents too Geophagus of Thorichthys, and Cribrheros, that would also be a better match up for your water.
Below Cribroheros rostratus
View attachment 1535078View attachment 1535079
Thank you for the input. The reason I’d considered the Tapajos was because I’d kept and had them spawn for me before.
That said, considering your suggestions, perhaps a group of Steindachneri or Pellegrini, T. Meeki, and possibly a couple of Nic’s? I’m looking for the best variety of color and traits, if that makes sense.
On a separate note, do you know of places to acquire many of these SA/CA species? I know of a couple, one local to me(TUIC) but I’m curious if there are other options out there that are preferred for better stock.
 
Thank you for the input. The reason I’d considered the Tapajos was because I’d kept and had them spawn for me before.
That said, considering your suggestions, perhaps a group of Steindachneri or Pellegrini, T. Meeki, and possibly a couple of Nic’s? I’m looking for the best variety of color and traits, if that makes sense.
On a separate note, do you know of places to acquire many of these SA/CA species? I know of a couple, one local to me(TUIC) but I’m curious if there are other options out there that are preferred for better stock.
There may be more sites, but these 2 along with TUIC are those I have dealt and had success with
Cichlids of the Americas. I just saw C rostratos here
Wet Spot Tropicals, I just saw Geo steindachneri, and a number of Thorichthys here.
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
There may be more sites, but these 2 along with TUIC are those I have dealt and had success with
Cichlids of the Americas. I just saw C rostratos here
Wet Spot Tropicals, I just saw Geo steindachneri, and a number of Thorichthys here.
Great, thank you. I’ve dealt with TUIC when Jeff had it, not since the new ownership though. I’ve also ordered from Wet Spot in the past with good success. Never heard of CotA. Any experience with Imperial Tropicals?
 
I love the Red Head Tapajos! Great tankmates would be any of the acara's or port cichlids, severums (no go with plants) chocolate cichlid, true parrot cichid, Urau, Oscar,etc.

My Geo Red Heads grew quite slowly, but I have heard they grow much quicker with very frequent water changes.....internet hearsay.

Ive got a plan for the next tank to be big and full of Geos....

Keep us posted!
I will for sure. I'm doing some planning now with species, trying to find compatible groups but also narrowing to local if possible to avoid shipping. I also want to buy younger ~2" fish and let them grow out. So far, there are a few species on local lists in consideration only an hour from me. Right now the possible candidate list consists of Geo. Pellegrini or Sveni, Crib Longimanus, Thor. Meeki or Ellioti, and H. Nicaraguensis.
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com