Cichlids similar in aggression to rainbow cichlids

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

HybridHerp

Fire Eel
MFK Member
May 18, 2012
1,192
86
66
New York
Hey, so, I'm needing to re-do my 75 and I'm thinking about what fish I want to stock the tank with. Its kind of a tough decision tbh. Normally, when keeping cichlids, I try and purposely plan a balance of power so that there's not some overcetralization of aggression between any two fish. Because of this, I'm always trying to be smart with my cichlid choices.

Beforehand, I was running an EBJD, 2 rainbow cichlids, an electric blue acara and 2 hecklii (thread fin acara) and they balanced each other out in terms of aggression and the tank had no issues. Currently though, I'm left with the electric blue acara and the rainbow cichlid. The rainbow is perhaps twice the size of the electric blue acara and is clearly more dominant a fish, although sadly it has chosen to be a dark colored and drabber fish instead of the bright yellows it used to display. Kinda stopped showing those when I got my EBJD, I guess because it was no longer top dog? Now the fish is definitely top dog but probably stressed from how drastically the tank changed (its pretty bare now, less hiding spots....that's going to be changing very soon).

Anyways, the rainbow is king atm but I don't quite like/trust the mix of just the two cichlids. I'm thinking of adding angelfish to the mix (once I get nice healthy ones to a good size) since I know temperament wise they will mix as well, but I'm debating if that's enough. In the past, I've noticed that my cichlids only really care about the other cichlids and ignore other fish, and it wouldn't surprise me if they ignored angelfish being that angels are relatively different in appearance and a little more different in behavior. What are some other cichlids I should consider that are in the same vein as a rainbow cichlid?

Currently, ideas that come to my mind are things like misc. cryptoheros species (not convicts, I mean I guess one would work but its not my thing anyways), thoricthyes species, things like that. I'm also possibly into the idea of a blood parrot (gasp) because I know how they work pretty well and I kinda have a special place in my heart for them but idk if that's what I want. Possibly considering doing an EBJD again as well (shrug). Ideally, I'd only want another normal bodied cichlid or two (unless angelfish would accomplish what I'm talking about, sorry if this is getting long winded and confusing). I was also thinking abut kribs but I have no idea if they'd be ignored or not, or bolivian rams but the size difference might be a concern.
 
My electric blue acaras shredded two adult veil angelfish, so they're no longer allowed to have angel tankmates. I keep my blue acaras with Inca Stone Fish.

Usually rainbows are fairly peaceful. I kept mine with severums, Laetacara, and Krobia.
 
Hrm, I don't plan on going for veil tail angels and am still willing to try the mix because my EBA is pretty reclusive, but I'll keep an eye out as well. My pearl gourami are left alone so I figure if they're fins are fine an angelfish should likely be fine too.

Totally forgot about Laetacara. I'd like the redder color that some of them get. Also, totally forgot Krobia are even a fish that exists haha. I forget if these are cryptoheros or if they are a different genus (I don't think they are but ???) but HRP's seem like a neat little fish if I only had a single. What fish is that in your profile pic ryansmith83? I guess my choices also come down to what fish I can locate and how much of a hole they'd burn into my pocket to get.
 
I have the 20 growing out in a 100 gal, all range from 2"-3". Other than a few Cory cats, and a pleco, they are the only fish in the tank.
At this point they are all less than a year old, and some pairs will probably be separated out in May or June if spawning is evident.
There are many social cichlids, like Geophagines, or these, and when I can, I like to house and grow them out in groups, how I feel, they look best, as opposed to random single individuals in a tank.
Looks very natural to me.
Of course there are cichlids that are loners or live in pairs in nature, and are always kept appropriately so





With enough space, even those that don't respond well to others, can be surprising, and act like they do in nature.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zb3v0VJTg5c
 
my only concern with a group of rainbows is tank space, and my concern with having two is if they try breeding the tank might get a little hectic...plus I'd rather not have them digging

hrmm...I'm almost considering rehoming him but idk anyone that would be interested or would do a group of them proper...decisions decisions
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com