Clown loach producing eggs

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo

Jen1782

Feeder Fish
Jul 16, 2018
3
3
3
40
Hi everyone, I am new here and want some advice. I am an amateur tropical fish keeper and have been searching the web for information about my clown loaches.
I have two loaches which I have had for 2.5yrs. they are of a good size and spend lots of time 'dancing' and swimming around the tank when not resting on their sides or in a cave I have made them between rocks.
On Thursday night I completed a complete water change and clean out and on Friday my female loach started laying bright orange eggs! Now, I have read that this is an almost impossible phenomenon in an aquarium, but it happened and I have pictures and videos of her laying and of the wiggling eggs to prove it... Links below if allowed as this is my first post. I captured a few wiggling eggs in a net and attempted to suspended them away from the other fish but alas (bad timing) we were spending the weekend away. I have got back and all eggs are gone (I imagine eaten) I'm very unhappy but was wholly unprepared.
I need some expert advice please: 1) how long do loaches spawn for? 2) how often do they spawn- when/is is likely to happen again? 3) what do I need to keep the eggs separated? I have a breeding trap but the eggs fell through the holes, do I need a mesh hatchery? They both remain often entwined, absorbed in each other and very pale.
Please no negative comments or reactions saying unlikely as I am a educated teacher who can tell that unusual behaviour teamed with amber globes and tube like forms dropping from the rear of my loach is likely to be eggs.
Many thanks for any help in advance. I can only upload these three pictures at the moment which show an egg emerging and an example of a couple of the twenty or so in the tank, I will post videos of the eggs moving when I work out how to (perhaps someone can help me)

IMG_20180713_175307795.jpg IMG_20180713_175254053.jpg IMG-20180716-WA0007.jpg IMG-20180716-WA0008.jpg
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey and J. H.
Congratulations! That's amazing. Guessing from other cyprinids, I'd say as long as the food, water conditions and temperature stay the same, they'll breed a few tmes a week (Goldfish, tiger barbs, rasboras & khuliis do that)
 
  • Like
Reactions: tlindsey
Congratulations! That's amazing. Guessing from other cyprinids, I'd say as long as the food, water conditions and temperature stay the same, they'll breed a few tmes a week (Goldfish, tiger barbs, rasboras & khuliis do that)
 
Thank you. I hope they do too. I'd love to hatch any eggs I can!


Welcome aboard
Congrats!
Personally I would log everything down such as temperature of aquarium water and temperature of water added after water change, ph and what foods you are feeding. I would suggest tossing in a sponge filter for future use or pickup a breeder box to put the eggs in.
 
id like to see the other pic and video. if it came out and its moving already maybe some type of parasite? even at 2.5 years old I doubt there eggs but if so best of luck
 
I don't see any eggs, the "red" looking thing in the pics looks like a camallanus worm. Neither of those loaches appear to be mature enough to spawn, and neither appear to be gravid in the pics. Sorry to be Debbie Downer, but I think that the teacher is mistaken.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: MrsE88
If you click on the CL images, then scroll through, there are pictures of actual CL eggs.

https://www.seriouslyfish.com/species/chromobotia-macracanthus/




iphon eggs into another tank, then raise fry, if you manage to do so you would be the first in aquarium


This has been accomplished, many times, by many people. The kicker is that the way this is typically done is by inducing egg production via hormones. Then the eggs are stripped, and fertilized by a males sperm that has been milked by the breeder. Bioaquatix in Florida has been breeding, and selling domestic bred CL's for years.

The "first" that everyone is waiting for is to see CL's successfully spawn (with viable fry produced) sans any form of hormones, or other manipulation by the breeder.
 
Ok, I’m glad I’m not the only one that doesn’t see eggs.

Op- Eggs that need to be fertilize externally can’t possibly wiggle right after being laid. They need time for the embryos to develop.

That being said, is that red thing the “egg” you are talking about?
Because you say “amber globes”, but I see red tubes. And yes, they look like worms. I thought maybe they were blood worms from feeding and that the eggs are just out of focus and impossible to see if you don’t know where to look.
Any update?
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com