Get Your MonsterFishKeepers Cap

Welcome to

The members of this forum have come together to share our knowledge and experiences of fish keeping. We want to answer your questions, offer advice and fill the galleries with pictures of the fish we have all grown to love.

We are a unique community of Fish Keepers who seriously take our hobby to extremes and the NEXT level. The majority of our fish collections include RARE & EXOTIC Species of all sizes, BIG FISH with BIG APPETITES and BIG TANKS. It's not easy for most people or other "regular" fish keepers to understand why we maintain this type of collection and spare no expense on this fascinating hobby.

Hopefully, through this site and discussion forums we can encourage the next generation of Monster Fish Keepers to have the same passion and love we have for the hobby and our Monster Fish .

As one of the founding members, I personally invite you to register and join us today. Currently you are viewing this site as our guest which only gives you limited access to view most discussions, articles and photo galleries.

Registration is FREE and very easy! When you register, you'll have instant access to....

  • • Post and participate in discussions about your passion for fish keeping
  • • Have your own Photo Gallery and the ability to upload your images
  • • View and comment on the gallery
  • • Participate in MFK contests, promotions, and discounts
  • • Use of private messaging to communicate with other community members

  • We're constantly striving to improve our community to help make your Monster Fish Keeping hobby fulfilling and interesting. Comments are welcome.



    Clown loaches: flashing? What's this by gills? And black spots

    Discussion in 'Freshwater Diseases and Health Issues' started by Cardeater, Oct 19, 2018.

    1. Cardeater

      Cardeater Jack Dempsey

      Real Name:
      Apr 14, 2018
      Likes Received:
      Trophy Points:
      Last Seen:
      Today at 12:54 AM

      Short version of issue:

      Ive been meaning to post about this for awhile but my old phone was too hard to get video with and then it bootlooped. I just got a new phone so:

      I want to get more pics but fish are hiding. I did get the video below:

      Also what is this by the Gill cover? I don't notice this on my old loaches. Also it seems like current can move it. I thoygth it may have been a mark but now I think it could be something else. New phone takes a bust of photos when I snap a pic so I could see that it is moved by the water.

      945449718.png IMG_20181019_184834_exported_233_1079709148347250647.jpg

      I read threads on about black spots and it seems to be harmless ( theorized to be from TDS changes in water). There's black spot disease from snails but these fish didn't have any spots in qT and my old loaches always had them. As I explain below , the spots reduced in number since I've been doing more frequent water changes. You can still see a few in the pic above but two others have more.

      Thanks for any input. Fish have been like this for like 6-7 weeks but I want to know if I should try treating for Gill flukes or something. In a QT tank I might have just tried general cure and ich x in case it's Gill flukes or ich hidden in the gills but I'm afraid to risk my big loaches unnecessarily.

      My only other theory is maybe it was from using stress coat too much when I saw an injury on my big loach awhile back.

      I wondering if it Gill flukes or hidden ich bc I can't see anything except what I point out in the pic. Gill glukes , I thought cause on Gill to stay open. The black worries me in case it's a Gill filament, mucus or something.

      Long version:
      That's the gist of my problem. Here's what I posted on including more detailed info asked for in sticky. I figured I'd post here as this site gets more traffic and might have more opinions.

      The short version is my young loaches have been flashing like this for like two months and I'm not sure if I should try treatments or if it could just be from the black spots that loaches can get (I read the long thread about how the theory is it's from TDS changes during water change). I know there's a black spot disease from snails but I haven't had snails in this main tank for over a decade and these clowns didn't have the spots in the QT tank. Also, my older loaches had black spots for years.

      The rainbowfish, pleco and old loaches don't flash at all.

      I haven't seen any white spots on any fish in here.

      The only thing I think may be unusual is this black/grey by their lower Gill covers. My old loaches don't have this nor do the rainbowfish nor the pleco.
      I kept trying to Google if this is a symptom of anything but haven't figured anything out. My new phone takes a burst of photos and it seemed like the water current moves what's rt that black thing is as it isn't static in the pics

      Not sure what this is below.

      More info:
      Three of the loaches and the rainbowfish we're from Divers Den on liveaquaria so they were quarantined, including some dip to eliminate ich. I had a lone clown loach LFS that I put in Aquarium Coop's med trip in. Two loavhes died a day after so I stopped treatment.

      I didn't see any signs of disease in them. I dewormed with a round of general cure, and I did two treatments of levamisole, second one two weeks after the first.

      I moved them over after 11 weeks of QT when I had new fish arriving for the QT.

      Black spots:
      One day I noticed they all had a bunch of black spots I read all the threads here about it and it seemed to be harmless and the 8 page thread speculated it was from TDS changes. The nitrates were under 5 in the QT but I noticed I had let nitrates get up to 40 on my 125g before water changes. Since then I've been doing 2-3 tomes a week 80% water changes and nitrates don't go over 20.

      The black spots disappeared almost entirely from two small loaches. They reduced in number on the two bigger new loaches. Ad I said, my old (20+ years) loavhes slwsys had spots.

      The small loaches flash like in the video by that rock and on the driftwood above. It seems like it decreased in frequency after I up water changes to every other day or every third day. I just videos that fish flashing but haven't seen any fish for it in the half hour I've been sitting by the tank. I used to be able to observe them doing umit anytime I stayed by the tank for more than 5 mins.

      Sticky post answers:

      ype of fish that are affected (common name and latin name if possible - common names vary worldwide, latin names don't!).
      * How long has the tank been set up for?
      20-21 years. No new fish until this batch for 15 years.

      * Size of tank (dimensions and volume).
      125g, 6ftx18"x22"

      * How is the tank being filtered?
      -Aquaclear 110 with extra matrix, no carbon, the ceramic media and the sponge that came with. Large intake sponge

      -Whisper 3
      HoT magnum
      Both of these hot rodded with matrix and Eheim Substrate Pro and an Aquaclear sponge in one Whisper 3 chamber

      -air stone running an ATI nydo sponge Pro 5

      -Aquaclear 70 powerhead running a stacked hydro 5 on top of a hydro pro 5.

      * Water temperature.
      Currently 79.3, heaters are set at 88.5

      * Your maintenance regime (e.g. how often water changes are carried out, what percentage of the water is changed each time, how often you clean your filter/s and how do you do this?)
      See above. I service the sponges about once a week in tank water except I sometimes just rinse the intake sponges with tap water. I don't service the main folters all at once. For example, I rinsed out the Aquaclear 110 sponge today and the air stone filter but left the double stack filter alone.

      * Has anything new been added to the tank recently? (fish, plants, live food, decor etc)
      Nothing new since fish were added in Aug. I use separate syphons and buckets to service this tank and the QT. I do this tank first before touching the QT tank.

      * What other fish are in the tank
      Original residents, 20+ years
      1 12" hypostomus pleco (someone on planet catfish identified it as such)
      2x clown loaches (was three but one jumped out during a water change by accident and I didn't notice it)

      * As detailed a description as possible of the symptoms the fish are exhibiting (remember a photograph can speak a thousand words).
      See above.

      * How long ago the affected fish were added to the tank, and how long the fish have been displaying symptoms.
      As said above, developed not long after I transferred them. Could have been something the OG residents were used to.

      * Your current water parameters - ammonia, nitrite, nitrate, pH (please don't say 'my water is fine, the levels are ok', we would like actual numbers from the test results).

      Ammonia and nitrites always zero. See above. Nitrayes:
      It never gets over 20 due to new water change schedule and often is under 10.

      The pH, I could never get a reading. Must be like 7.5 bc I always get 7.6 on API pH test and 7.4 on API high range.

      Tap water is Lake water Michigan . I think it's moderately hard, 1ppm chlorine.
    2. Cardeater

      Cardeater Jack Dempsey

      Real Name:
      Apr 14, 2018
      Likes Received:
      Trophy Points:
      Last Seen:
      Today at 12:54 AM

      So, I think the black by gills may just be normal for some clown loaches.

      I watched this video today and it looks the same as three of my loaches:

      The fish also don't seem to flash that much. I'll try watching them for an extended time tonight but previously if I watched for ten minutes, I'd see some of them rub against that rock. Now it seems more rare.

      I'm thinking maybe too much stress coat was irritating them. I was worried about a fish having a scratch .I actually ran out of it and have used only prime last two water changes so maybe that's why they flash less.

      Also, if it were flukes or hidden ich, they'd probably show more symptoms by this point, I'm guessing?

      That and that I quarantined then and did some preventive deworming and used general cure (plus all of the fish but one went through the Divers Den protocol) probably means disease is unlikely.
    3. Cardeater

      Cardeater Jack Dempsey

      Real Name:
      Apr 14, 2018
      Likes Received:
      Trophy Points:
      Last Seen:
      Today at 12:54 AM
      Maybe excess stress coat caused flashing

      I think it was too much stress coat that caused the flashing. I hadn't been using it itger than a capful or so and I noticed the clown loaches were rarely flashing.

      I saw a nick on one of the fish last week so I did water changes and added a lot of stress coat. After that, I noticed the clown loaches flashing again.

      The tiny scrape seems to have healed so my last two water changes, I decreased the stress coat. Just yesterday, I again only be used a capful or two (probably unnecessary but my logic is the little bit to help slime coat may help them considering prime doesn't have any). I haven't seen the loaches flashing.

      Just to be clear, when I increased my dose of stress coat (I was too lazy to measure but ilid pour for line a second and estimate it was about 10-12 or more capfuls) I noticed flashing. When I decreased it to almost nothing, I haven't seen any flashing.

      I read somewhere that much stress coat could irritate the gills by coating them so there could be dometsome to this correlation I observed.
    4. tlindsey

      tlindsey Silver Tier VIP

      Real Name:
      Thomas Lindsey Sr.
      Aug 6, 2011
      Likes Received:
      Trophy Points:
      Last Seen:
      Today at 1:15 AM
      I use safe and never had the flashing issue with Clown Loaches.

    Share This Page