Could a ornate birchir really go in a 50g tank

  • We are currently upgrading MFK. thanks! -neo
So what your saying is i cant keep a ornante in there for life and some people on the cichlid section said i could keep on in there but lol im not going to argue with you bruce cause i no that you no your fish over just about anyone on this site
 
lol tanks man out of all of the polys i think ornate are my favorite and i saw frontosas and i feel in love with them
 
Check Annes stickies, she has great info on keeping Polypterus.
 
Hello,

i've read those words about the ornates in "live aquaria" ... now i know the exact translation of the one-of-a-kind disturbing description done by Sterba (or Mergus - i don't know who had copied whom ...).
First - ornates are fast growing! When i bought mine in spring 2008 he had only 8cm (approx. 3,15 inch) in lenght ... now he has 20cm (approx. 8 inches) in lenght. I#m feeding only 1-2 times a week (but then plenty of feeders, worms etc.).

Here as a newbie in spring 2008:

pornatipinnis002.jpg


Here 2 months ago - shortly before he killed the Sajica ...

ornipulch01.jpg


My ornate is doing well with other bichirs and with his "best friend", a Channa pulchra. This is my second ornate i'm keeping (the first one was growing too fast - and i didn't have a new tank - in other words - i didn't had the place created to positioning the new big tank) ...
This ornate also "loves" cichlids - especially at night. My "Left-over" (i had used this as name for my last cichlid - all others were eaten by my former ornate) was left over as a bizarre puzzle with some parts missing - they caused that fat belly unmasking the offender ...

To make dimensions clearer ... ornates are not only dangerous to small fish - the cichlids weren't small, "Left-over" was a prey one would commonly did not think about ... see him on the pic a bit on the left side (the Weeksi on the pic is approx. 10 inches long):

week004.jpg


The size: Ornates are growing fast up to a lenght of 35-40cm (approx. 13-15 inches) - then the ornates will explore the slowness concerning growing ...
Those 60cm+ (23 inches+) ornates are old specimens ... it tooks decades to grow up to this lenght.
Back to the fish you want to combine: Maybe it will work, maybe not. I've read much about the combination ornate & other fish ... my experience: Cichlids do not work (will end as feeders) but other keepers had made other experiences.
It's a bit like the disagreeable discussion about the combination Oscar & Bichir - maybe it works, maybe it's a catastrophe ...

Greetings

Uwe
 
Thanks Uwe and that stickies that anne has are really helpful and do you really think a couple of ornates in a tank with a group of four frontosas could take down the fronts if i got them at the same length prolly about 5-6" in the future? And if they could would weeksii be better, or what could i do
 
MonsterFishKeepers.com